Zwarte Piet in Groningen

Zwarte Piet in Groningen

Tuesday, November 26, 2013

Zwarte Piet - Samantha Van Horn

When I first heard about the tradition of Zwart Piet I was very shocked. I found it extremely offensive and wrong. I know that there is no racist intent behind it but that does not mean that it doesn't come across that way, and it does not mean that it doesn't hurt people. As an American I can look at this situation and easily see why it is wrong, but that is because I have been exposed to things like this my entire life. Our country has a long history with racism and discrimination, and seeing a character such as this is very disheartening. As I said earlier, there is no racist intent, but it does make people feel uncomfortable. I feel that the way in which people reacted to those who stood up and expressed their opinions and feelings on the matter is the biggest problem. I think you should take a step back and see things from their eyes and try to understand why they feel the way that they do. How would you feel if something that you identified with was poorly represented around your entire country? I don't think that this tradition should be ended but some changes should be made: whether it be painting faces many colors or not painting them at all. Zwarte Piet does have racist connotations and something needs to be done about it.

1 comment:

  1. Sinterklaas is traditional, with absolutely no racist intent. But it is a celabration and every one should be enjoying this time of year. But it seems harder than it looks to make a big difference like painting no one. The childeren look at a positive way to Zwarte Piet. They see him as a happy funny good man who gives them candy. But that does not mean that other peaple should feel offenced by him. A lot of people see this problem unnessecery. They say that when people make a problem out of Zwarte Piet they make it ricism. But other people just feel offensed. This is a dillema. I personaly think they both have good points and I think that there needs to be a solution where both ''sides'' canlive with. Maybe that every year a couple more other coloured Pieten will come. So that in 3 years you will have only ''Rainbow Pieten'' . So that Zwarte Piet will not go away, and that no one feels discriminated by it. It is a celabration for everyone. and that is the way how éveryone should see it.

    ReplyDelete