Ah nu moet ik over Zwarte Piet schrijven. Dit is een leuk onderwerp nee? Echter, is het voor mij eenvoudig. Ik ben van de mening die je de gevoelens van andere mensen overwegen moeten als je een ding doet. Als een ding andere mensen ongemakkelijk of ongelukkig maakt, moet jij deze ding niet doen, hmm? Ik ga een voorbeeld geven. Misschien ik wandel buiten graag naakt. Misschien ik hou van knuffelen. Misschien ben ik aan het naakt wandelen en ik zie jou op de straat. Ik knuffel je. Nu ben jij ongemakkelijk. Ik wilde niet jou ongemakkelijk maken. Ik wilde alleen mijzelf gelukkig zijn, maar mijn acties hebben je aangedaan. Mijn voornemen in deze situatie is niet slecht maar het maakt niet uit. Het is niet juist voor mij te acteren, behalve ik denk eerst over de gevoelens van anderen.
Zo is het ook met Zwarte Piet. Ik kan waarderen dat hij een oude traditie is. Hij is een deel van de Nederlandse Kerstmis cultuur, maar misschien is het tijd voor hem een deel van de geschiedenis van de cultuur te zijn. Hij maakt veel mensen ongemakkelijk. En deze mensen zijn ontdaan over ras. Zwarte Piet maakt dat mensen zich gediscrimineerd voelen. Het maakt niet uit wat z'n bedoeling is.
Aan het eind van de dag, is het beter attent te zijn. Geef niet naakte knuffelen aan vreemden.
Zwarte Piet in Groningen
Wednesday, December 11, 2013
Tuesday, December 10, 2013
Zwarte Piet Discussion- Zander Harlan
The discussion about weather Zwarte Piet is racist or not, in my opinion comes down to religious values. In my opinion the tradition is not racist at all because it comes from a viable source. I believe that most of the people making the argument that he is racist do not know the facts. They don't know the factual story about St.Nicholas and how he brought Zwarte Piet up to the Netherlands. In the original story Piet was black and therefore I think the tradition should stand. Santa Claus is part of our tradition, and in most senses he is pictured as obese and over weight. This could be thought of as discriminatory against the huge obese community found in the United States. This really doesn't make any logical sense, but it is tradition and therefore I think the Zwarte Piet situation should be viewed in the same light.
Some may argue against this by saying that the way he is depicted, with a black face and very red lips, makes it racist. I do agree with people in this sense, but I think that since it is a Dutch tradition that has been celebrated for decades there is no reason to take it away now. They aren't celebrating that slavery is a good thing by any means, so the tradition should stand. Just think if a group of people tried to take away the tradition you had been celebrating for so long.
Some may argue against this by saying that the way he is depicted, with a black face and very red lips, makes it racist. I do agree with people in this sense, but I think that since it is a Dutch tradition that has been celebrated for decades there is no reason to take it away now. They aren't celebrating that slavery is a good thing by any means, so the tradition should stand. Just think if a group of people tried to take away the tradition you had been celebrating for so long.
Sunday, December 8, 2013
Zwarte Piet in Duitsland?
Hoi,
in Duitsland vieren we ook Sinterklaas op 6 dec, maar het is niet zo belangrijk als in Nederland. Toen ik klein was kreeg ik een beetje voedsel (zoals noten en oranjes) op een teller, maar dat was bijna alles. We hebben ook iemand die op Zwarte Piet lijkt: 'Knecht Ruprecht'. Maar die is niet zwart en ook niet zo bekend. Ik ken hem alleen maar omdat er een pianostuk van Robert Schumann met zijn naam is. Maar ik ken zijn geschiedenis niet en weet alleen dat hij de bozen kinderen bestraft.
Vroeger laas ik vaak 'Struwelpeter', een bundel van geschiedenissen voor kinderen geschreven van Hermann Hoffmann in het 19. eeuw. In één geschiedenis zijn er drie jongen, die zich over een Moor vrolijk maken. Om ze te bestraffen doopt Sinterklaas de drie in inkt. De moraal ervan is dat je je niet moet vrolijk maken over mensen die anders zijn dan jij. Kennen mensen in Nederland deze geschiedenis? Als ja, zie je er in verbinding met Zwarte Piet?
in Duitsland vieren we ook Sinterklaas op 6 dec, maar het is niet zo belangrijk als in Nederland. Toen ik klein was kreeg ik een beetje voedsel (zoals noten en oranjes) op een teller, maar dat was bijna alles. We hebben ook iemand die op Zwarte Piet lijkt: 'Knecht Ruprecht'. Maar die is niet zwart en ook niet zo bekend. Ik ken hem alleen maar omdat er een pianostuk van Robert Schumann met zijn naam is. Maar ik ken zijn geschiedenis niet en weet alleen dat hij de bozen kinderen bestraft.
Vroeger laas ik vaak 'Struwelpeter', een bundel van geschiedenissen voor kinderen geschreven van Hermann Hoffmann in het 19. eeuw. In één geschiedenis zijn er drie jongen, die zich over een Moor vrolijk maken. Om ze te bestraffen doopt Sinterklaas de drie in inkt. De moraal ervan is dat je je niet moet vrolijk maken over mensen die anders zijn dan jij. Kennen mensen in Nederland deze geschiedenis? Als ja, zie je er in verbinding met Zwarte Piet?
Zwarte Piet - Sammy Pressman
The Zwarte Piet issue is a very interesting case which elicits a strong response from every side on the issue. To be honest, when I first heard about it, I did not care all that much, as I could not picture Zwarte Piet in my head so it did not seem like a huge deal to me. However, when I first saw a picture of Zwarte Piet, in what many Americans would call "black face", I was very shocked. That was my original ethnocentric reaction, as I am someone from a culture where black face is a huge taboo. For instance, if I were to dress up in a costume and use black face, no doubt many people here at the university would be disgusted. Yet Zwarte Piet must also be analyzed from a culturally relative position in order to understand it.
The main point about Zwarte Piet as a part of Dutch culture is that I do not think it is intentionally trying to be racist. Yet intentional or not, in the end it can still be construed as racist. However, this comes down to two very different countries with very different histories, which is why cultural relativism must come into play when thinking about this issue. The United States has a history of slavery and racism dating back hundreds of years, where blacks were marginalized and abused not only physically but socially too. Some of those impacts can still be seen today, in everything from the criminal justice system, where blacks are no doubt treated unfairly, to the educational system. The accumulation of these problems has led to a feeling of "white guilt" in our country, where many white people feel bad about the past and present treatment of minorities. As such, we feel that anything that offends them offends us, not because we can identify with how they feel, but because we feel bad that yet another bad thing is happening to them.
In the Netherlands, the opposite is true. While the Dutch held slaves, many of them were far off in the colonies, and those who lived in the mainland Netherlands were very disconnected from what was happening to the slaves. This is my explanation for why Zwarte Piet is not seen as racist by many Dutch. To you, it is merely tradition, something which has gone on for nearly a century and never faced scrutiny until very recently. Yet just because it has gone on for so long without scrutiny does not make it ok to continue. I know that it is very hard for you to understand why we think it is wrong. This is merely my opinion, and you have yours. I do not think that everything that offends somebody should be banned, that would lead to the banning of pretty much everything. However, Zwarte Piet, while not intentional, is still an accumulation of centuries of misfortune which are still affecting many today, and could be changed. I do not think the tradition needs to go away entirely, it seems very festive and fun, it should just be done in a way which can incorporate everyone. Once again, understand that this is only my ethnocentric opinion, and I am sure yours is very different.
Zwarte Piet - Jeffrey Bennett
I think Zwarte Piet is maybe not intended to be racist, but the Afros, big earrings, and large lips suggest otherwise. I believe here in the US we are overly politically correct about everything as it is impossible to please everyone and have someone not be offended. But when something clearly offends such a large cross-section of the population, it may be time to reevaluate the issue. Clearly Zwarte Piet has caused such a large controversial reaction. In my opinion traditions are important, and should be protected and honor, but when the tradition is so steeped in racial history, maintaining the status quo is certainly inappropriate. I think simple changes, such as the multi-color/rainbow Piets, would be a great step in the right direction. The first year or two of change is sure to be upsetting, but subsequent years will become much easier and soon the controversy will be forgotten, and the holiday can return to being a fun, joyous time for everyone.
Saturday, December 7, 2013
The Implications of Blackface
For me, it's hard to imagine celebrating something as controversial as Zwarte Piet in blissful ignorance. As I understand it, a fair comparison can be made between the Dutch festival and American Christmas; both are perceived as the most joyous of days. Yet, for thousands of Netherlanders (And non-white people everywhere), it's perceived as highly offensive, perpetuating negative racial stereotypes that should have long been done away with. It's a festival that has (mostly) white people painted in blackface, dressed in red lipstick, and sporting a frizzy hair wig, harkening back to offensive caricatures of old.
My only other experience with blackface was when I saw it used in two classic films: The Birth of a Nation, and The Jazz Singer. In the former film, blackface was worn by white actors to portray slaves in Antebellum South, primarily because the film was pro-Ku Klux Klan (associating the practice with racism).
seen here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Birth-of-a-nation-klan-and-black-man.jpg
In the latter, however, blackface is used as a sort of assimilation-agent -- the star was a Jewish immigrant -- used to usher in his career in the midst of an antisemitic America (applying a much more reasonable connotation to the practice).
seen here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Al_Jolson_Jazz_Singer.JPG
But is the festival actually racist? Surely the intent is for everyone to have a good time, but the disturbing underlying implications keep it from doing so. To be honest, I don't think the intent really matters; people are offended by it and we should respect their stance. If Amsterdam is truly as progressive as it prides itself to be, it should factor in all of its citizens' opinions, including those who find pain in the midst of others' joy.
Vragens over Zwarte Piet
Hoi! Ik heet Mackenzie :)
De Zwarte Piet discussie die nu heel belangrijk in Nederland is, is iets die ik niet voor dit jaar gewist had. Net als andere Amerikanen vind ik de Zwarte Piet traditie racistisch te zijn. Maar ik kan ook zien hoe dit een belangrijke traditie voor uw samenleving is. Zwarte Piet is een van de weinige sterke tradities die jullie nog hebben als samenleving en ik weet ook dat jullie de traditie veranderd hadden, zodat het nu minder racistisch is en ik vind dat ook goed. Ik denk, dat jullie de traditie van Zwarte Piet niet volledig laten moeten, maar jullie moeten ook nadenken van uw sterkste groep immigranten, de Surinamers, en hoe ze voelen zich over deze traditie. Wat denken jullie van dit onenigheid van Zwarte Piet? Denken jullie dat de traditie een beetje meer veranderen moet?
Tot ziens!
-Mackenzie
De Zwarte Piet discussie die nu heel belangrijk in Nederland is, is iets die ik niet voor dit jaar gewist had. Net als andere Amerikanen vind ik de Zwarte Piet traditie racistisch te zijn. Maar ik kan ook zien hoe dit een belangrijke traditie voor uw samenleving is. Zwarte Piet is een van de weinige sterke tradities die jullie nog hebben als samenleving en ik weet ook dat jullie de traditie veranderd hadden, zodat het nu minder racistisch is en ik vind dat ook goed. Ik denk, dat jullie de traditie van Zwarte Piet niet volledig laten moeten, maar jullie moeten ook nadenken van uw sterkste groep immigranten, de Surinamers, en hoe ze voelen zich over deze traditie. Wat denken jullie van dit onenigheid van Zwarte Piet? Denken jullie dat de traditie een beetje meer veranderen moet?
Tot ziens!
-Mackenzie
Monday, December 2, 2013
Vragens over de Zwarte Pieten
Hallo,
Ik heb wat vragen voor de Nederlandse studenten. Wat denkt jullie over de Zwarte Pieten? Hoe belangrijk zijn de Zwarte Pieten voor jullie? Waarom? Het lijkt erop dat heel veel mensen uit andere landen zorgen hebben over de Zwarte Pieten. Voor Amerikanen, lijken de Zwarte Pieten schaamteloos racistisch. Maaken jullie hier ook zorgen over?
Ik heb wat vragen voor de Nederlandse studenten. Wat denkt jullie over de Zwarte Pieten? Hoe belangrijk zijn de Zwarte Pieten voor jullie? Waarom? Het lijkt erop dat heel veel mensen uit andere landen zorgen hebben over de Zwarte Pieten. Voor Amerikanen, lijken de Zwarte Pieten schaamteloos racistisch. Maaken jullie hier ook zorgen over?
Sunday, December 1, 2013
Zwarte Piet - Alex Edema
I think that the issues involving Zwarte Piet are quite different than what the United States faced during the Civil Rights era in the 1950's and 1960's. Although they are different, I think that they're both offensive to a lot of people in different ways.
In the US we had to deal with segregation and learning how to try and treat each other equally in all aspects of life. Right now in the Netherlands, the main issue seems to be about ignorance towards other people's feelings and not as much about looking down at people of color.
The situation with Zwarte Piet is much more difficult to deal with in my opinion because there isn't an easy way to pass a law that ends a holiday tradition. It's a different, more difficult type of racism because it isn't based on hatred which makes it harder to actually define as racism. Pinpointing the problems in certain people's beliefs about Zwarte Piet is more difficult because they don't think of the tradition as racist. It's difficult to overcome a situation like this because people relate the holiday to childhood and in the innocence of childhood it's difficult to imagine any racist or offensive practices actually meaning something negative.
I think that the easiest solution would be to make the Piet character any type of ethnicity. Remove the racial aspect from the character and he simply becomes a helper of Sinterklaas.
In the US we had to deal with segregation and learning how to try and treat each other equally in all aspects of life. Right now in the Netherlands, the main issue seems to be about ignorance towards other people's feelings and not as much about looking down at people of color.
The situation with Zwarte Piet is much more difficult to deal with in my opinion because there isn't an easy way to pass a law that ends a holiday tradition. It's a different, more difficult type of racism because it isn't based on hatred which makes it harder to actually define as racism. Pinpointing the problems in certain people's beliefs about Zwarte Piet is more difficult because they don't think of the tradition as racist. It's difficult to overcome a situation like this because people relate the holiday to childhood and in the innocence of childhood it's difficult to imagine any racist or offensive practices actually meaning something negative.
I think that the easiest solution would be to make the Piet character any type of ethnicity. Remove the racial aspect from the character and he simply becomes a helper of Sinterklaas.
Zwarte Piet Matt Pauszek
The initial response I had to the Dutch tradition of Zwarte Piet and one I feel other individuals have is that this tradition is racist. With tens of thousands of Dutch people painting their faces black, donning Renaissance-style jerkins and pantaloons, and assuming the persona of "Black Pete," it is easy to say that there are many racist stereotypes in play. Although this was my initial reaction, I then began thinking more deeply and asked myself, what even is racism? I feel as if the larger issue is the apparent huge misunderstanding of what “racism” is and how “racism” works. I believe we can’t start labeling that Zwarte Piet is rascist (or has rascist elements) or isn’t rascist, without even discussing as a society what racism even means.
Along with the misunderstanding of the actual term racism, I firmly believe the issue of Zwarte Piet is one for the Dutch people to debate and not something for me as an American to have a problem with. I learned that the majority of the Dutch population does not view Zwarte Piet with any intent to be discriminatory and as far as the Dutch are concerned, Zwarte Piet is a quintessential Dutch holiday tradition and their childhood memories are filled with only positive associations. I think to judge a culture that I have never experienced is wrong and not very intelligent.
On the other hand though this holiday seems similar to my American experience with Thanksgiving which I just celebrated recently. I love the time I get to spend with my family and the excessive amounts of great food I eat, but I can't help but feel as if this holiday if perceived differently by say Native Americans. This holiday originated around a time in which many Native Americans died and were forced off their land in order for the white European Americans to colonize. While I enjoy the holiday and have no negative intentions behind it, many Native Americans could be offended just like many dark skinned individuals may be offended by Zwarte Piet.
Overall I hope you all have a great Christmas on the 5th and that Sinterklaas and Zwarte Piet bring you lots of gifts!
Along with the misunderstanding of the actual term racism, I firmly believe the issue of Zwarte Piet is one for the Dutch people to debate and not something for me as an American to have a problem with. I learned that the majority of the Dutch population does not view Zwarte Piet with any intent to be discriminatory and as far as the Dutch are concerned, Zwarte Piet is a quintessential Dutch holiday tradition and their childhood memories are filled with only positive associations. I think to judge a culture that I have never experienced is wrong and not very intelligent.
On the other hand though this holiday seems similar to my American experience with Thanksgiving which I just celebrated recently. I love the time I get to spend with my family and the excessive amounts of great food I eat, but I can't help but feel as if this holiday if perceived differently by say Native Americans. This holiday originated around a time in which many Native Americans died and were forced off their land in order for the white European Americans to colonize. While I enjoy the holiday and have no negative intentions behind it, many Native Americans could be offended just like many dark skinned individuals may be offended by Zwarte Piet.
Overall I hope you all have a great Christmas on the 5th and that Sinterklaas and Zwarte Piet bring you lots of gifts!
Zwarte Piet- Jackie Khutorsky
As an American and as a person of non-African desent, I feel doubly removed from the Zwarte Piet debate that is currently transpiring within the Netherlands. However, as someone who has experienced racism and is from a country with a dark history with slavery, I feel as though I have a different perspective to add to the Zwarte Piet debate. Not long ago, black face was widely accepted within America. In fact, the lead character in the 1927 movie The Jazz Singer, remains in black face for the majority of the movie.
Here is a picture:
As you can see, this character strongly resembles Zwarte Piet. By using stereotypical features like big lips, black skin, and tight curly black hair, the character in the movie and Zwarte Piet remain images that are offensive and disturbing to many people. Instead of depicting a race in an honest way, both images rely on heavily biased and stereotypical conceptions that are overwhelmingly offensive. Needless to say, dressing up in black face is no longer cultuarlly acceptable in America and should no longer be tolerated in the Netherlands as well.
While Zwarte Piet is understandably a favored and treasured tradition within in the Netherlands, why would a country that activaly promotes tolerance ever want to continue to offend thier citizens and other black people around the world by keeping Zwarte Piet? No one wishes to abolish Zwarte Piet altogether but rather what if some slight adjustments were made? Perhaps the Zwarte Piet could be rainbow or natural skin colored. This would eliminate all offensive feelings while saving a tradition treasured by many Dutch people. Though there is no denying that traditions are meant to be shared among many generations, there is no restriction on whether traditions can be slightly altered in order to become progressive and compliment with current social norms. In conclusion, I think that the image of Zwarte Piet should be slightly altered in order to become non-offensive to all races.
Here is a picture:
As you can see, this character strongly resembles Zwarte Piet. By using stereotypical features like big lips, black skin, and tight curly black hair, the character in the movie and Zwarte Piet remain images that are offensive and disturbing to many people. Instead of depicting a race in an honest way, both images rely on heavily biased and stereotypical conceptions that are overwhelmingly offensive. Needless to say, dressing up in black face is no longer cultuarlly acceptable in America and should no longer be tolerated in the Netherlands as well.
While Zwarte Piet is understandably a favored and treasured tradition within in the Netherlands, why would a country that activaly promotes tolerance ever want to continue to offend thier citizens and other black people around the world by keeping Zwarte Piet? No one wishes to abolish Zwarte Piet altogether but rather what if some slight adjustments were made? Perhaps the Zwarte Piet could be rainbow or natural skin colored. This would eliminate all offensive feelings while saving a tradition treasured by many Dutch people. Though there is no denying that traditions are meant to be shared among many generations, there is no restriction on whether traditions can be slightly altered in order to become progressive and compliment with current social norms. In conclusion, I think that the image of Zwarte Piet should be slightly altered in order to become non-offensive to all races.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
