Zwarte Piet is something almost any American would see and immediately think is offensive. In our country, something like Zwarte Piet would be protested heavily and face serious opposition. In the USA, traditions and customs often have to change as time goes by, and certain things are no longer publicly accepted. For example, we had our own tradition of using black face in entertainment. It was common practice for white actors to use black face in theater and movies for much of the 1800's and into the 1900's. This was largely seen as a non issue while it was in practice because of the lack or rights African-Americans had in the United States. However, as time progressed, ideas changed and by the late 1930's and 1940's black face was associated with bigotry and kept out of theater and film for the most part especially when the Civil Rights Movement took hold in the 50's and 60's.
Another example of traditions being changed in the United States can been in the use of Native American mascots for universities and sports teams. For colleges, universities are only allowed to have the nickname or mascot of a Native American tribe if they are respectful and the tribe agrees to let the school use it. For example the Florida State University Seminoles are allowed to use the Seminole nickname because the seminole tribe granted them permission. However other schools have had to abandon their mascots because they are now considered offensive, even though at one time they were thought to be okay.
Zwarte Piet is a tradition that many do see as offensive. However traditions take time to change. No one wants to give up on something they hold so dearly, or see as a non issue. It's very easy to say something is harmless and all in good fun when it is not hurting you. At some point though, something does need to be done so that Sinterklaas can be enjoyed by everyone, not just those that aren't offended by Zwarte Piet. While this is a long process it starts with acknowledging that something should be done. It is the Netherland's tradition though so I believe change should when the majority of the country is ready for it. It should not been forced upon the Netherlands, otherwise many might resent the celebration for what was taken out of it. Eventually though a compromise should be reached.
I can't wait to hear your thoughts on the subject.
Zak Piech
Zwarte Piet
ReplyDeleteThe discussion regarding Zwarte Piet is going world-wide last weeks. It seems to be a trending topic everywhere. In the Netherlands however the discussion is more regarding the international commotion regarding the topic.
To understand the Zwarte Piet character I will explain something about the Sinterklaas-tradition. In general Sinterklaas (Saint Nicolas) has a lot similarities with Father Christmas (Santa Claus). They both live far away, Father Christmas at the North Pole, Sinterklaas in Spain. Both are visiting the children once a year, giving them presents. Father Christmas drops his presents under the Christmas tree, the myth doesn’t tell how he comes into the houses. Sinterklaas drops his presents next to the fireplace. He is riding his horse over the roofs of the houses and his (colourless) servants enter the houses through the chimney flues. It’s not surprising the servants are black when they are up on the roof again, especially when they have to serve all children of the Netherlands and Belgium in one night only. Racism has never been an issue for the citizens of both countries as everyone knows it’s not about black skinned people. The problem is raised by foreigners who don’t know the tradition and only saw the black painted people.
Some residents in The Netherlands now lobby to replace Zwarte Piet by Rainbow Piet. So the servants of Sinterklaas can be of any colour. How to explain to the young children? Daddy is storing his paints in the chimney flue and Piet opened all the cans on his way down? And how about the reindeers Father Christmas use? Why are the animal activists not claiming the United Nations for this useless habit to transport the presents with a sleigh and reindeers from the North Pole to the children? We have planes, trains, ships and trucks for decades, so why he uses these animals?
In my opinion it’s a little overdone to bother the United Nations with this harmless tradition without proper investigation. Let the U.N. focus to the real live! Polls turned out the majority of the Dutch (coloured and non-coloured) don’t want to change the tradition of Sinterklaas and Zwarte Piet and I’m one of them.
Rimada