The debate over whether Zwarte Piet is racist can be viewed in very different lights. The idea itself of Zwarte Piet is not racist in and of itself. However, the modern day representation of Zwarte Piet with blackface and big red lips play upon the stereotypical portrayal of African slave laborers. This depiction is, how I see it, racist. The feeble claim that Zwarte Piet came down the chimney and was covered in soot is not really a viable excuse for their blatantly African characteristics. Outsiders ask why aren't his clothes covered in soot as well, which quickly discredits the chimney excuse. Really, there is no reason for Zwarte Piet to be black other than the tradition behind it. Understandably, it is difficult to change things that a society feels are tradition. Yet, when said tradition makes certain groups of people feel uncomfortable and discriminated against, it is time for change.
It seems as if Zwarte Piet is not meant to be racist. Keeping that in mind, if you were to view this tradition from the shoes of someone of African descent, you would be appalled by its implicit racism. I don't think that the tradition of Zwarte Piet should be stopped, only altered in a way that relieves some of the racist undertones of the event. Clearly the event means a lot to the Dutch people so I would like to ask why some of the Dutch are so reluctant for change?
No comments:
Post a Comment