Zwarte Piet in Groningen

Zwarte Piet in Groningen

Tuesday, November 26, 2013

Zwarte Piet: Morgan Rondinelli

The easiest way I can think about or try to understand this tradition is by comparing the Zwarte Piet imagery to previous imagery and racism in the United States. It is no secret that America used to have slavery and during this time and for a long time after there were vast amounts of racist ideas and imagery. Most Americans viewed African Americans as lower than white Americans and thought it was right that they were working for the Americans. Nonetheless, with the gradual elimination of slavery, the Civil War, and then the huge Civil Rights Movement, the majority American opinion has changed. Because this change has been occurring for many decades, today most Americans see people of all skin colors as equal and they find any of these old ideas or images very racist. This is why the Zwarte Piet tradition in the Netherlands surprises me. This country also moved away from slavery many years ago. Yet, the imagery and presentation of African Dutch as servants to Sinterklaas, sometimes being silly and unintelligent, or also having black lips seems to once a year carry on the ideas of slavery despite the absence of slavery. I know it is not quite correct to compare practices of two countries because of differing cultural and moral opinions. However, it just seems strange to me that in a country that also moved past slavery these colonial-based images still seem present during the winter holiday.

Overall, I am trying to understand this tradition myself and am trying to think about it in ways that I can maybe relate to, despite my upbringing in another country. The other way I try to understand this tradition of Zwarte Piet is by imagining myself in the shoes of the African Dutch. This also makes me feel very uncomfortable about the character Zwarte Piet. I know I cannot truly understand what these African Dutch feel when they see Zwarte Piet but I can at least do my best to try to understand what the pain or discomfort of this season is like for some of them. For me personally, as a Jewish American, I already feel extremely uncomfortable around the Christmas holiday season. This is one aspect I can understand: not being able to fully participate in winter holiday traditions. This is how I somewhat imagine African Dutch feel during the time of Sinterklaas. If they feel uncomfortable and hurt by the Zwarte Piet character perhaps they cannot fully engage in the holiday. Parades may be very upsetting for them and they most likely will also not be joining in the tradition of dressing up like Zwarte Piet. Of course it should be noted that my discomfort is only due to the fact that I do not celebrate the holiday, not because part of my identity is possibly being negatively portrayed, as many African Dutch feel from Zwarte Piet. Nonetheless, by imagining what seeing Zwarte Piet feels like to the African Dutch maybe I can better understand their pain. I know for a fact that if Christmas parades showed men and women with dark, curly brown hair; big noses; and being "cheap" about handing out gifts to the children I would be extremely offended and uncomfortable. While the negative characteristics of Zwarte Piet have been toned down quite a bit over the past few years, such as removing the Surinamese accent and having Zwarte Piet seem less unintelligent, the figure and its colonial origins still remain.

My suggestion about how some Dutch can try to understand why many African Dutch are upset is to advise them to reflect on past experiences they have had or imagine a situation in which something negative was said about their race or some other aspect of their identity. They should try to imagine what it would be like to have this representation paraded around towns year after year. Maybe by putting themselves in the African Dutch's shoes, as I tried to do, more people can begin to see why Zwarte Piet is sometimes painful to others.

No comments:

Post a Comment