Zwarte Piet in Groningen

Zwarte Piet in Groningen

Tuesday, November 26, 2013

Zwarte Piet - Jan Smith

Hallo.

The debate over Zwarte Piet is very surprising for most Americans. We have a concept of 'political correctness' here in the United States that makes things like Zwarte Piet taboo. Basically, we believe that if something will make other people feel hurt or upset, we should respect their feelings. Not every American likes the idea of political correctness. However, no American that I know would ever wear blackface, for any reason. That's how deeply engrained the taboo is here.

Although it's an American taboo, that doesn't mean it's a Dutch taboo. However, I would like to suggest that maybe Dutch people should make blackface a taboo as well. Here are a few reasons why.

  • Zwarte Piet, despite what some people say, certainly does represent a person of African descent. Here is why.
    • Origins: Zwarte Piet came into existence in the height of the colonial period, in the mid-19th century. 
    • Imagery: Zwarte Piet is dressed in clothes from an era in which black people were taken from their homeland and sold as slaves. Although the Netherlands hasn't had slavery, Dutch ships often carried slaves.
    • In short, because of the history of the character, we cannot say that he is just a white boy who fell down a chimney. He was originally intended to be a black person, and his clothing shows that he still seen as a black person, from a very racist era.
  • Your friends and fellow citizens are hurt by Zwarte Piet.
    • This is the idea of 'political correctness'. You have the freedom to say and do what you want, but should you really do something that makes someone feel horrible?
  • You don't have to get rid of Sinterklaas or Piet... just consider modifying the tradition.
    • Sinterklaas is a beautiful festival. In America, where Christmas has become commercialized and commodified, nobody truly anticipates the holiday season. But my friends from Europe all talk about what a magical time of year it is. They talk about family, tradition, delicious food, and a magical quality that is foreign to most of us Americans. 
    • Zwarte Piet is ruining this tradition. The refusal to separate Zwarte Piet from Sinterklaas could ruin the holiday itself. 
    • In short, Sinterklaas isn't a racist holiday in and of itself... but it could be. If Zwarte Piet ruined the Sinterklaas festival, it would be truly tragic.
One last thought - consider your response to accusations of racism. We say in the US that the worst thing you can call a white person is racist. I'm white myself, and if someone told me I was racist, I would be very, very upset. But you shouldn't be angry. Instead you should think about what people are saying and try to see what they see. Usually, when someone says you did something racist, it's true... it doesn't mean you're racist as a person, but it means that something you did or said made them feel bad. Most racism is unintentional.

The way you respond to this makes a huge difference. If you get mad and aggressive, then that's even more racist. If you keep doing something even though you know it makes people feel horrible, then it becomes intentional. And if you intentionally do something racist, then maybe that does make you racist.

In short... no, the Netherlands is not a racist nation... no, Dutch people are not racist... no, Sinterklaas is not a fundamentally racist festival... but Zwarte Piet is a very, very racist character. 

These are my thoughts. Feel free to take them or leave them,

- Jan

PS - here's an interesting link you might want to read. A bit about the history of blackface in the United States. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackface

No comments:

Post a Comment