Zwarte Piet in Groningen

Zwarte Piet in Groningen

Tuesday, November 26, 2013

Zwarte Piet - Jennifer Nguyen

Is Zwarte Piet really racist? Through an American lens, it's kind of hard to to not see Zwarte Piet having some sort of racist connotation. America's got a history with slavery and segregation and all sorts of negative things associated with different races, so to see something like Zwarte Piet is rather shocking. While I've seen arguments that say Zwarte Piet is a harmless, silly character, I find them all a bit hard to digest. He originated when slavery was still present and acceptable, and while he's changed little by little through the years, his roots are still apparent.
Intention is not the problem here. He is well-intentioned yes. So are lots of other people, and traditions. The football team here, the Washington Redskins, are just showing their appreciation of their football team. These people are just fans, they're not out to become horrible racist people with a radical extremist agenda. Despite that, the term Redskins is offensive to Native Americans, and the people are asking to change it. To me, that's comparable to Zwarte Piet. Zwarte Piet is not currently made to be a symbol of racism, and is not meant to invalidate any person of any color. His looks are offensive, though. It's based on a black stereotype that can make people uncomfortable.

It's hard to let go of tradition and to change. Outsiders suddenly trying to interfere in a tradition that they had no part of and know very little about is frustrating -- infuriating even. However, compromise must be made since not everyone can be shut off in their own little bubble. The world is incredibly connected, and very little can stay private forever. Every action will affect another person, and consideration should be taken to avoid offending others. Not to mention, hasn't Zwarte Piet changed before? First, he was created. Then, he was given a name. Nobody tried to riot over that. Later, he was given a nicer disposition. The people didn't start sending death threats to anyone. Surely it wouldn't be hard to change the character; he doesn't have to be completely wiped out from the tradition of Sinterklaas. Compromise and change is important. For a country that has changed so much in response to the outside world, it's surprising how stubborn the stance is on Zwarte Piet when all around the world the people are asking for change. 

No comments:

Post a Comment