My personal views on Zwarte Piet as a character and as a tradition are NOT as important as my desire to understand the importance of the character to the Dutch people, and where the seemingly unanimous defensive attitude towards the Sinterklaas tradition comes from.
It seems very strange that a country that has been through so much change in the past fifty years would be so opposed to changing the character of Zwarte Piet and therefore the Sinterklaas tradition in this, of all circumstances, when this holiday relates not only to ethnicity but to religion as well.
Looking from the outside, the Netherlands has made incredibly progressive choices in the formation of it's current identity. Shedding religion, homophobia, and a remarkable volume of tradition, the Netherlands appear as an incredibly pragmatic and rational society, not only when compared with other European countries but also when compared to America itself. Honestly, Dutch society trumps many aspects of American society, allowing citizens to love and marry who they desire, eliminating stigmas about soft drugs, regulating the phenomenon of prostitution instead of fighting it and putting prostitutes in an even more delicate predicament, and letting go of religious zealotry. But one thing I cannot wrap my head around is why this character and this tradition are so important in the midst of all of this.
Sinterklaas, to my understanding, follows that St. Nicholas was an ex-pope, an incredibly powerful figure of the Christian religion. Clearly stemming from a religion that remarkably few Dutch people practice, it's hard to understand why the tradition is so dear to the Dutch people. I'm actually surprised there isn't more ambiguity in the argument, if presented with this scenario of Sinterklaas and the tradition, without knowing how Americans felt about it collectively, or knowing how the Dutch feel about it collectively, I would expect (as usual) America to want to get involved and to try to change Sinterklaas, which it has. But, I would also expect the Dutch people to shrug their shoulders, rather than take up arms for their holiday tradition, as I really would not expect it to be a big deal to the Dutch people, the "sacredness" of an old tradition seems a very strange platform for a people who have embraced change so actively and repeatedly over the past half-century.
Then bring in Zwarte Piet.
Suddenly we have a catalyst for conflict. With racism and discrimination still so prevalent in the world, it is a trigger for arguments to imitate any one race. This is why the tradition of "black face" baffles so many Americans, because if the argument is so mundane and trivial, why does it truly matter if it is changed?
Why should the Dutch care if Piet is no longer Zwarte, and if Piet had many colors? Especially if it breeds so much bad publicity and so many arguments to keep the tradition withstanding. Why not identify Piet based on his (quite noticable!) outfit, or on his behavior, or even on the make-up on the lips? A white Dutch man can just as easily be identified as one of St. Nicholas' helpers if he wears the outfit and wears bright make-up on his lips, and proceeds to hang around St. Nicholas and act as a Piet traditionally would, so why is it necessary that he have a black face?
I know that the Dutch do not see Zwarte Piet as racist, and I know you will read 100 arguments for why it is from my fellow American bloggers, so instead of arguing whether Zwarte Piet is racist or not, I merely want to ask what the big deal is for the Dutch People, the most pragmatic, negotation-friendly, adaptive society around, in changing one detail of an old religious holiday to avoid all of this controversy and nation-wide sensationalism?
This being said, I understand that I see through an "American" lens and that I am by no means Dutch, and so I would like to hear responses on my argument, so I can hope to understand the Dutch point of view on this issue. Thank you for your time.
-Allen McClelland
No comments:
Post a Comment