Zwarte Piet in Groningen

Zwarte Piet in Groningen

Tuesday, November 26, 2013

Zwarte Piet

Zwarte Piet is a very new and interesting topic to me.  Before just a couple weeks ago when we talked about this tradition in class, I had never heard of it.  When I heard what it was all about for the first time, I did think it was racist because in America if anyone painted their face black it would definitely be considered racist.  However, I understand why the Dutch people would believe otherwise.  Zwarte Piet is a tradition for all of you, just as Americans have many traditions as well.  A tradition is hard to look at as something wrong as it has always been the way that it is.  Traditions are normalized no matter if there are racist aspects within them or not, because they are the way people believe they are supposed to be.  I understand this and how Dutch people have a hard time seeing why Zwarte Piet may be offensive to outsiders or people of color.  But if you are someone who has not grown up with this tradition it could easily be seen as racist towards black people. Traditions are hard to change and I would understand why the Dutch people may be extremely against this as they see no problem with Zwarte Piet, but there could definitely be some alterations that could be made in order to take away any racist aspects within this tradition.  

It is clear that Zwarte Piet is not intended to be racist, it is just a tradition which may have a racist underlay that many people don't recognize.  Even though Zwarte Piet was not created to offend people of color, it does.  I believe that the Netherlands as a whole needs to make sure they understand where the colored people are coming from when they say they are offended by this tradition and they need to take that into account and possibly alter the way the tradition is celebrated.  I think it is very important for both sides to be heard.  The colored people should understand that the Dutch don't mean to offend them, and the Dutch people need to understand that the people of color do take offense to Zwarte Piet.  I think once there is a mutual understanding, there are many solutions to this issue, which would conclude in everyone being satisfied.

I would love to hear all of your opinions on this topic,

Moriah Stapf 

No comments:

Post a Comment