From my perspective, it is hard to say. One has to begin by determining if racism can be inherent. I don't believe Zwarte Piet is intended to be racist, at least not in this day and age. It seems to me to be more of a continued tradition than an intentional overt display of racism. However, it is still offensive to many people of color. Here it is not intent, but perceived response that matters. If something is offensive to a specific racial group, then that thing is racist. In this case it is not what Zwarte Piet represents that determines if it is racist or not, but how it makes certain racial groups feel. It directly offends people of color in the Netherlands.
In America, there is a hugely charged atmosphere regarding race relations. For example, just in the last week or so a trend was started on Twitter where black students described their specific experiences here, at the University of Michigan (#bbum or "being black at UMich"). This was without any specific incident acting as a prompt; it was just a general venting of frustration and anger over feeling mistreated. If something such as Zwarte Piet were to be introduced here, into this sort of atmosphere, there would be nothing short of full scale protests, maybe an organized march on the capitol or two. People would not accept such a tradition whether they were black or white because it would be seen as horrifyingly racist.
I understand that it is one of the last real traditions in the Netherlands. I don't however, believe that modifying the tradition to make Zwarte Piet less offensive would harm the tradition in any way. The parades, the excitement, and all the usual events surrounding the tradition can remain the same. The only change required to make this tradition fun for everyone is to take the black out of the subservient "black Pete." For example, I've heard of attempts to just have a "natural" Pete, where the actors that play Pete simply don't use black face and retain their natural skin color. Other attempts at reconciliation have been rainbow Petes. Neither of these solutions will have any detrimental effect on the overall tradition of Sinterklaas, but they will remove the racism that surrounds it.
So yes, I suppose I do believe Zwarte Piet is racist, and all other considerations (such as "its tradition," or "it isn't intended to be racist") are irrelevant. To make Sinterklaas a wholesome, enjoyable tradition for everyone in the Netherlands, Zwarte Piet should be changed to remove the inherent racism.
I look forward to hearing your response! I'm very interested to hear your opinion on the topic.
-Jonah Harmon
No comments:
Post a Comment