Zwarte Piet in Groningen

Zwarte Piet in Groningen

Tuesday, November 26, 2013

Zwarte Piet

As an American, I have the capability of seeing the Zwarte Piet issue from a different perspective, through a different cultural lens.  I think a reason that this debate is raging is that many people do not see the racism involved in the Zarte Piet tradition.  I don't believe any Dutch person would intentionally take action to offend someone, but I think many people don't realize its effects.  Those that take offense have for a long time had no voice on this matter, but are just now coming out into the open to share their feelings about Zwarte Piet. My advice, listen to what they have to say.  It may surprise you.
And I don't want to come across as a condescending foreigner saying, "Shame on you!" so I'll give you an example of this that exists in America.  Here, we have various sports franchises and other groups that have for a long time offended various Native American tribes.  The professional football team, the Washington Redskins, as well as the baseball team, the Cleveland Indians both bear Native Americans as their mascots. Throughout the years, various groups have shown their outrage at these teams and would love to see their names changed.  They find it very disrespectful to see their culture depicted as simplistic, brutal fighters.  However, franchise owners and sports fans don't want to change.  They are not intending to be racist, and they don't want to change tradition.  And more than likely, change will not come for a long time if at all.  As a more or less neutral observer (I am not Native American, nor do I pay close attention to sports) it is still difficult for me to desire a change.  Part of me wants to believe that nobody finds these teams very offensive, but a part of me knows this is not true.  If more voices spoke out and shared that they were truly, deeply hurt, I would be very much inclined to change the franchise names.

No comments:

Post a Comment