I personally have mixed feelings on the subject. I don't believe that anyone is trying to hold discriminatory feelings toward colored people by supporting Zwarte Piet. Zwarte Piet is simply a tradition that those people want to hold on to. I also can understand why some people might get upset by the image of Zwarte Piet. To them Zwarte Piet might appear as Sinterklaas' slave. The goofy attire of Zwarte Piet might also be considered as offensive.
Here in America we have a similar debate that is happening. For years American sports teams have used names and mascots that refer to Native American tribes and people. These mascots and names often reinforce stereotypes about Native Americans, and are sometimes viewed as derogatory in nature. Because of this controversy organizations like the NCAA (National Collegiate Athletics Association), have decided to ban the use of mascots that depict Native Americans in an unfitting way. Native Americans have begun movements to get the names of these mascots changed. Many non-Native Americans believe that the names have no intent to be offensive and believe the names should be kept out of tradition. So this whole scenario could be considered very similar to the situation with Zwarte Piet.
So in the end I believe that while the intent for Zwarte Piet to be racist isn't there; there are still racist undertones to the character of Zwarte Piet. I'm not Dutch, have never been to Holland, and have never personally experienced a Zwarte Piet celebration so I can't really decide what should be done, if anything, about this so that will be a decision left up to the Dutch.
No comments:
Post a Comment