The debate over whether Zwarte Piet is racist can be viewed in very different lights. The idea itself of Zwarte Piet is not racist in and of itself. However, the modern day representation of Zwarte Piet with blackface and big red lips play upon the stereotypical portrayal of African slave laborers. This depiction is, how I see it, racist. The feeble claim that Zwarte Piet came down the chimney and was covered in soot is not really a viable excuse for their blatantly African characteristics. Outsiders ask why aren't his clothes covered in soot as well, which quickly discredits the chimney excuse. Really, there is no reason for Zwarte Piet to be black other than the tradition behind it. Understandably, it is difficult to change things that a society feels are tradition. Yet, when said tradition makes certain groups of people feel uncomfortable and discriminated against, it is time for change.
It seems as if Zwarte Piet is not meant to be racist. Keeping that in mind, if you were to view this tradition from the shoes of someone of African descent, you would be appalled by its implicit racism. I don't think that the tradition of Zwarte Piet should be stopped, only altered in a way that relieves some of the racist undertones of the event. Clearly the event means a lot to the Dutch people so I would like to ask why some of the Dutch are so reluctant for change?
Zwarte Piet in Groningen
Saturday, November 30, 2013
Wednesday, November 27, 2013
Zwarte Piet - Tara van Veen
Hallo!
I hope that everyone is having a good week. This will be my blog post about Zwarte Piet. I am going to try and be as impartial as possible.
In the United States, we have gone through years of the Civil Rights Movements, a battle that is still on going in order to ensure that the United States is a country where everyone can have equal rights. We have come a long way in government protected rights, especially for racial minorities and women, but we still have a lot to accomplish. I think that this movement has helped Americans to see that even unintentional racism can still be hurtful to others. However, we are still, Americans. It is a lot easier to critique a culture when we are looking from the outside in.
Both of my parents celebrated this tradition growing up. My dad grew up in a small Dutch neighborhood in Quebec. His parents immigrated there just a few months before he was born. My dad's recollection of the experience had nothing but positive things to say about Zwarte Piet. He talks about how Zwarte Piet would give him treats and help him get his present from Sinterklaas. It was a character he was fond of, helping him get to Sinterklaas.
However, the people acting as Zwarte Piets are not people of color, they are white, painting themselves black and fulfilling stereotypes of people of color. These Zwarte Piets have curly black hair, big red lips, and the way that Zwarte Piets act, enforces unfair stereotypes of people of color. Not all people of color run around doing flips nor are they any less intelligent.
Although years ago this tradition may not have seemed racist, the fact that people have come out and said that it hurts and offends them, shows that it is hurting part of your country. If this is one of your favorite holidays, would you not want to let everyone in The Netherlands celebrate it with the same excitement that you have? The entire situation seems like it is a lose-lose situation. Although it is a cherished holiday, it is still enforcing racial stereotypes of people of color. It is too bad that it has become a worldly issue rather than something that The Netherlands, as a country, could have solved on their own.
Tuesday, November 26, 2013
Zwarte Piet - Samantha Van Horn
When I first heard about the tradition of Zwart Piet I was very shocked. I found it extremely offensive and wrong. I know that there is no racist intent behind it but that does not mean that it doesn't come across that way, and it does not mean that it doesn't hurt people. As an American I can look at this situation and easily see why it is wrong, but that is because I have been exposed to things like this my entire life. Our country has a long history with racism and discrimination, and seeing a character such as this is very disheartening. As I said earlier, there is no racist intent, but it does make people feel uncomfortable. I feel that the way in which people reacted to those who stood up and expressed their opinions and feelings on the matter is the biggest problem. I think you should take a step back and see things from their eyes and try to understand why they feel the way that they do. How would you feel if something that you identified with was poorly represented around your entire country? I don't think that this tradition should be ended but some changes should be made: whether it be painting faces many colors or not painting them at all. Zwarte Piet does have racist connotations and something needs to be done about it.
Zwarte Piet - Jennifer Nguyen
Is Zwarte Piet really racist? Through an
American lens, it's kind of hard to to not see Zwarte Piet having some sort of
racist connotation. America's got a history with slavery and segregation and
all sorts of negative things associated with different races, so to see
something like Zwarte Piet is rather shocking. While I've seen arguments that
say Zwarte Piet is a harmless, silly character, I find them all a bit hard to
digest. He originated when slavery was still present and acceptable, and while
he's changed little by little through the years, his roots are still apparent.
Intention is not the problem here. He is
well-intentioned yes. So are lots of other people, and traditions. The football
team here, the Washington Redskins, are just showing their appreciation of
their football team. These people are just fans, they're not out to become
horrible racist people with a radical extremist agenda. Despite that, the term
Redskins is offensive to Native Americans, and the people are asking to change
it. To me, that's comparable to Zwarte Piet. Zwarte Piet is not currently made
to be a symbol of racism, and is not meant to invalidate any person of any
color. His looks are offensive, though. It's based on a black stereotype that
can make people uncomfortable.
It's hard to let go of tradition and to
change. Outsiders suddenly trying to interfere in a tradition that they had no
part of and know very little about is frustrating -- infuriating even. However,
compromise must be made since not everyone can be shut off in their own little
bubble. The world is incredibly connected, and very little can stay private
forever. Every action will affect another person, and consideration should be
taken to avoid offending others. Not to mention, hasn't Zwarte Piet changed
before? First, he was created. Then, he was given a name. Nobody tried to riot
over that. Later, he was given a nicer disposition. The people didn't start
sending death threats to anyone. Surely it wouldn't be hard to change the
character; he doesn't have to be completely wiped out from the tradition of
Sinterklaas. Compromise and change is important. For a country that has changed
so much in response to the outside world, it's surprising how stubborn the
stance is on Zwarte Piet when all around the world the people are asking for
change.
Zwarte Piet Zak Piech
Zwarte Piet is something almost any American would see and immediately think is offensive. In our country, something like Zwarte Piet would be protested heavily and face serious opposition. In the USA, traditions and customs often have to change as time goes by, and certain things are no longer publicly accepted. For example, we had our own tradition of using black face in entertainment. It was common practice for white actors to use black face in theater and movies for much of the 1800's and into the 1900's. This was largely seen as a non issue while it was in practice because of the lack or rights African-Americans had in the United States. However, as time progressed, ideas changed and by the late 1930's and 1940's black face was associated with bigotry and kept out of theater and film for the most part especially when the Civil Rights Movement took hold in the 50's and 60's.
Another example of traditions being changed in the United States can been in the use of Native American mascots for universities and sports teams. For colleges, universities are only allowed to have the nickname or mascot of a Native American tribe if they are respectful and the tribe agrees to let the school use it. For example the Florida State University Seminoles are allowed to use the Seminole nickname because the seminole tribe granted them permission. However other schools have had to abandon their mascots because they are now considered offensive, even though at one time they were thought to be okay.
Zwarte Piet is a tradition that many do see as offensive. However traditions take time to change. No one wants to give up on something they hold so dearly, or see as a non issue. It's very easy to say something is harmless and all in good fun when it is not hurting you. At some point though, something does need to be done so that Sinterklaas can be enjoyed by everyone, not just those that aren't offended by Zwarte Piet. While this is a long process it starts with acknowledging that something should be done. It is the Netherland's tradition though so I believe change should when the majority of the country is ready for it. It should not been forced upon the Netherlands, otherwise many might resent the celebration for what was taken out of it. Eventually though a compromise should be reached.
I can't wait to hear your thoughts on the subject.
Zak Piech
Another example of traditions being changed in the United States can been in the use of Native American mascots for universities and sports teams. For colleges, universities are only allowed to have the nickname or mascot of a Native American tribe if they are respectful and the tribe agrees to let the school use it. For example the Florida State University Seminoles are allowed to use the Seminole nickname because the seminole tribe granted them permission. However other schools have had to abandon their mascots because they are now considered offensive, even though at one time they were thought to be okay.
Zwarte Piet is a tradition that many do see as offensive. However traditions take time to change. No one wants to give up on something they hold so dearly, or see as a non issue. It's very easy to say something is harmless and all in good fun when it is not hurting you. At some point though, something does need to be done so that Sinterklaas can be enjoyed by everyone, not just those that aren't offended by Zwarte Piet. While this is a long process it starts with acknowledging that something should be done. It is the Netherland's tradition though so I believe change should when the majority of the country is ready for it. It should not been forced upon the Netherlands, otherwise many might resent the celebration for what was taken out of it. Eventually though a compromise should be reached.
I can't wait to hear your thoughts on the subject.
Zak Piech
Stephanie Brown over Zwarte Pieten
Ik vind de discussie over Zwarte Piet heel interessante. Ik weet het niet hoe mensen niet een probleem te zien. Mijn clas gingen naar een lezing van Professor Duyvendak van de Universiteit van Amsterdam. Hij praten over allochtoon vs. autochtoon maar hij maakte duidelijk dat de meeste importat Nederlandse waarden waren mensen rechten. Of soms mensen zijn gekwest met de traditie, dan waarom is dit niet belangrijk? Daar zijn heel veel manieren om dit probleem te compromitteren. Zelfs als je dit niet als racisme, heeft het nog steeds beledigd veel mensen. Ik heb dat sommige mensen zeggen dat de kleur is afkomstig van de schoorsteen gehoord, maar dit is duidelijk niet het geval voor de rood lip kleur. Ze zijn het maken van excuses voor. Het kan geen kwaad iedereen om de traditie te veranderen, maar het is kwetsen van mensen zoals het is.
Stephanie Brown
Stephanie Brown
Stephanie Brown
Hallo!
Ik ben een student bij de Universeteit van Michigan. Ik studeer biologie and scheikunde. Ik wil een apotheeker zijn en ik wil geneesmiddelenonderzoek doen. Ik woon met mijn beste vriendin op campus. Wij spelen op een voetbal team met onze andere vrienden twee keer per week. Ik hou van mijn liefde bij school maar ik mis mijn famile wel eens. Waneeer ik thuis ben, mijn paarde rijden en ik zie alle mijn middelbare school vrienden. Wanneer ik niet mijn huiswerk doen, ik hou van koken of de t.v. show "Bones" kijken. ik houd van de winter en de sneeuw, dus dit is mijn favoriete tijd van het jaar.
Ik ben een student bij de Universeteit van Michigan. Ik studeer biologie and scheikunde. Ik wil een apotheeker zijn en ik wil geneesmiddelenonderzoek doen. Ik woon met mijn beste vriendin op campus. Wij spelen op een voetbal team met onze andere vrienden twee keer per week. Ik hou van mijn liefde bij school maar ik mis mijn famile wel eens. Waneeer ik thuis ben, mijn paarde rijden en ik zie alle mijn middelbare school vrienden. Wanneer ik niet mijn huiswerk doen, ik hou van koken of de t.v. show "Bones" kijken. ik houd van de winter en de sneeuw, dus dit is mijn favoriete tijd van het jaar.
![]() |
| Dit is de scheikunde gebouw |
Zwarte Piet
Zwarte Piet is a very new and interesting topic to me. Before just a couple weeks ago when we talked about this tradition in class, I had never heard of it. When I heard what it was all about for the first time, I did think it was racist because in America if anyone painted their face black it would definitely be considered racist. However, I understand why the Dutch people would believe otherwise. Zwarte Piet is a tradition for all of you, just as Americans have many traditions as well. A tradition is hard to look at as something wrong as it has always been the way that it is. Traditions are normalized no matter if there are racist aspects within them or not, because they are the way people believe they are supposed to be. I understand this and how Dutch people have a hard time seeing why Zwarte Piet may be offensive to outsiders or people of color. But if you are someone who has not grown up with this tradition it could easily be seen as racist towards black people. Traditions are hard to change and I would understand why the Dutch people may be extremely against this as they see no problem with Zwarte Piet, but there could definitely be some alterations that could be made in order to take away any racist aspects within this tradition.
It is clear that Zwarte Piet is not intended to be racist, it is just a tradition which may have a racist underlay that many people don't recognize. Even though Zwarte Piet was not created to offend people of color, it does. I believe that the Netherlands as a whole needs to make sure they understand where the colored people are coming from when they say they are offended by this tradition and they need to take that into account and possibly alter the way the tradition is celebrated. I think it is very important for both sides to be heard. The colored people should understand that the Dutch don't mean to offend them, and the Dutch people need to understand that the people of color do take offense to Zwarte Piet. I think once there is a mutual understanding, there are many solutions to this issue, which would conclude in everyone being satisfied.
I would love to hear all of your opinions on this topic,
Moriah Stapf
It is clear that Zwarte Piet is not intended to be racist, it is just a tradition which may have a racist underlay that many people don't recognize. Even though Zwarte Piet was not created to offend people of color, it does. I believe that the Netherlands as a whole needs to make sure they understand where the colored people are coming from when they say they are offended by this tradition and they need to take that into account and possibly alter the way the tradition is celebrated. I think it is very important for both sides to be heard. The colored people should understand that the Dutch don't mean to offend them, and the Dutch people need to understand that the people of color do take offense to Zwarte Piet. I think once there is a mutual understanding, there are many solutions to this issue, which would conclude in everyone being satisfied.
I would love to hear all of your opinions on this topic,
Moriah Stapf
Zwarte Piet: Morgan Rondinelli
The easiest way I can think about or try to understand this tradition is by comparing the Zwarte Piet imagery to previous imagery and racism in the United States. It is no secret that America used to have slavery and during this time and for a long time after there were vast amounts of racist ideas and imagery. Most Americans viewed African Americans as lower than white Americans and thought it was right that they were working for the Americans. Nonetheless, with the gradual elimination of slavery, the Civil War, and then the huge Civil Rights Movement, the majority American opinion has changed. Because this change has been occurring for many decades, today most Americans see people of all skin colors as equal and they find any of these old ideas or images very racist. This is why the Zwarte Piet tradition in the Netherlands surprises me. This country also moved away from slavery many years ago. Yet, the imagery and presentation of African Dutch as servants to Sinterklaas, sometimes being silly and unintelligent, or also having black lips seems to once a year carry on the ideas of slavery despite the absence of slavery. I know it is not quite correct to compare practices of two countries because of differing cultural and moral opinions. However, it just seems strange to me that in a country that also moved past slavery these colonial-based images still seem present during the winter holiday.
Overall, I am trying to understand this tradition myself and am trying to think about it in ways that I can maybe relate to, despite my upbringing in another country. The other way I try to understand this tradition of Zwarte Piet is by imagining myself in the shoes of the African Dutch. This also makes me feel very uncomfortable about the character Zwarte Piet. I know I cannot truly understand what these African Dutch feel when they see Zwarte Piet but I can at least do my best to try to understand what the pain or discomfort of this season is like for some of them. For me personally, as a Jewish American, I already feel extremely uncomfortable around the Christmas holiday season. This is one aspect I can understand: not being able to fully participate in winter holiday traditions. This is how I somewhat imagine African Dutch feel during the time of Sinterklaas. If they feel uncomfortable and hurt by the Zwarte Piet character perhaps they cannot fully engage in the holiday. Parades may be very upsetting for them and they most likely will also not be joining in the tradition of dressing up like Zwarte Piet. Of course it should be noted that my discomfort is only due to the fact that I do not celebrate the holiday, not because part of my identity is possibly being negatively portrayed, as many African Dutch feel from Zwarte Piet. Nonetheless, by imagining what seeing Zwarte Piet feels like to the African Dutch maybe I can better understand their pain. I know for a fact that if Christmas parades showed men and women with dark, curly brown hair; big noses; and being "cheap" about handing out gifts to the children I would be extremely offended and uncomfortable. While the negative characteristics of Zwarte Piet have been toned down quite a bit over the past few years, such as removing the Surinamese accent and having Zwarte Piet seem less unintelligent, the figure and its colonial origins still remain.
My suggestion about how some Dutch can try to understand why many African Dutch are upset is to advise them to reflect on past experiences they have had or imagine a situation in which something negative was said about their race or some other aspect of their identity. They should try to imagine what it would be like to have this representation paraded around towns year after year. Maybe by putting themselves in the African Dutch's shoes, as I tried to do, more people can begin to see why Zwarte Piet is sometimes painful to others.
Overall, I am trying to understand this tradition myself and am trying to think about it in ways that I can maybe relate to, despite my upbringing in another country. The other way I try to understand this tradition of Zwarte Piet is by imagining myself in the shoes of the African Dutch. This also makes me feel very uncomfortable about the character Zwarte Piet. I know I cannot truly understand what these African Dutch feel when they see Zwarte Piet but I can at least do my best to try to understand what the pain or discomfort of this season is like for some of them. For me personally, as a Jewish American, I already feel extremely uncomfortable around the Christmas holiday season. This is one aspect I can understand: not being able to fully participate in winter holiday traditions. This is how I somewhat imagine African Dutch feel during the time of Sinterklaas. If they feel uncomfortable and hurt by the Zwarte Piet character perhaps they cannot fully engage in the holiday. Parades may be very upsetting for them and they most likely will also not be joining in the tradition of dressing up like Zwarte Piet. Of course it should be noted that my discomfort is only due to the fact that I do not celebrate the holiday, not because part of my identity is possibly being negatively portrayed, as many African Dutch feel from Zwarte Piet. Nonetheless, by imagining what seeing Zwarte Piet feels like to the African Dutch maybe I can better understand their pain. I know for a fact that if Christmas parades showed men and women with dark, curly brown hair; big noses; and being "cheap" about handing out gifts to the children I would be extremely offended and uncomfortable. While the negative characteristics of Zwarte Piet have been toned down quite a bit over the past few years, such as removing the Surinamese accent and having Zwarte Piet seem less unintelligent, the figure and its colonial origins still remain.
My suggestion about how some Dutch can try to understand why many African Dutch are upset is to advise them to reflect on past experiences they have had or imagine a situation in which something negative was said about their race or some other aspect of their identity. They should try to imagine what it would be like to have this representation paraded around towns year after year. Maybe by putting themselves in the African Dutch's shoes, as I tried to do, more people can begin to see why Zwarte Piet is sometimes painful to others.
Zwarte Piet
Tradities zijn belangrijk en moet worden gevierd. Bijvoorbeeld, heeft mijn familie op kerstavond een traditie om sushi te eten. Maar, mijn traditie beledigt alleen de vis. Na verloop van tijd, veranderen culturen. Nieuwe mensen immigreren. Nieuwe ideeën zijn altijd gevormd. Zwarte Piet is niet een racistisch karakter gemaakt, maar mensen over de hele wereld blijven om het te zien als een vooroordeel tegen hun raciale identiteit. Ik begrijp dat de meeste Nederlanders de traditie niet willen veranderen. Maar een compromis moet worden gemaakt om aan de behoeften van collega Nederlanders tegemoet te komen. Wil Nederland inclusief te zijn? Mensen moeten comfortabel en geaccepteerd in hun thuisland voelen. Vooral rond de feestdagen.
Zwarte Piet Discussion
While there is certainly an argument to be made that
tradition is important, traditions can and do change over time to suit shifting
cultural sensitivities. The character of
Zwarte Piet may not be intended as a racist caricature or meant to offend Black
people in the Netherlands or anywhere else in the world, but that doesn’t
change the fact that a great number of people see it as demeaning and detrimental
to their racial identity. It is not
enough to merely recognize the fact that people are offended by a particular
characteristic of the tradition (namely the painting of people’s faces), but
steps must be taken to adapt the tradition to changing cultural and racial
sensitivities. The United States had a
similar cultural institution at the end of the 1800s and into the first half of
the 1900s in the form of minstrelsy, which diminished in popularity over time
as people realized how offensive they were to some members of society. Even though some would argue that minstrel
shows were not intended to be racist or offensive and that there simply weren’t
Black performers available or allowed to play the roles in certain places, as
national awareness of racial identity and sensitivity grew, these traditions
were widely recognized as no longer being appropriate or acceptable. Minstrel shows are now almost virtually
condemned and seen as racist. Although
the Netherlands does not have the same complicated and volatile racial history
that the United States does, it is still important to recognize and respect the
impact that these traditions have on people and the offense that it
causes. To us in the United States, it
is almost unimaginable to think of a tradition like this continuing on into
this decade, but it is not fair to compare the histories and traditions of two
different countries. Comparison,
however, is not the point. The point is
simply this: it is important not only to
listen to the concerns, opinions, and complaints of Dutch citizens who are
opposed to and offended by the Zwarte Piet tradition. An on-going dialogue and discussion about the
social and cultural repercussions of this tradition must take place, and people
should be prepared to make changes to better accommodate the sensitivities of
those who find this tradition offensive.
Zwarte Piet: Naomi Spoelman
I'm not going to use this post to try to convince you that Zwarte Piet is racist or that Zwarte Piet is offensive to various people. I know that my opinions are not going to change yours and that sometimes having an outsider tell you that something you are doing is "wrong" causes defenses to be raised. So instead I am just going to speculate about various things that may make changes to this tradition so difficult to deal with.
Do you think that your Sinterklaas traditions would be fundamentally changed if characteristics of Zwarte Piet were to be changed? From an outsider's perspective, it seems as though the story of Sinterklaas is already quite intricate and, if the color of Zwarte Piet's skin were changed, there wouldn't really be any variance to the story except the name of the helper. There have already been changes to the character throughout history, such as subdued characteristics, smaller painted lip, and even changing the original story from it being about Sinterklaas recruiting children from Africa to the Piets being black because of soot from the chimney. Additionally, it seems as though if Piet were "natural" colored, then the soot story could actually be used.
There have been various attempts to make the helpers of Sinterklaas more neutral in the color of their skin. One initiative was to introduce "Rainbow Piet" but this was met with death threats. (Here is an interesting website that shows the history of Zwarte Piet, the changes he has undergone in the past, and the possible story that could be used in order to introduce Rainbow Piet: http://www.stnicholascenter.org/pages/zwarte-piet/) Another was "Natural Piet" but this too was not accepted. Do you think that it would be easier to change the color of Zwarte Piet's skin if "Zwarte" wasn't part of his name? For instance, if the character had always been known as simply "Piet" or "Piet de Nuttig" do you think it would be easier to change a characteristic, such as the color of the skin? Perhaps a different approach could be taken... Do you think that if other racial characteristics were taken away (large red lips, curly black hair, gold hoops, etc.), would it matter as much that their skin was painted black? Do you think that black can ever really be just a color when it is painted on someone's skin?
Finally, do you think that this is a tradition that is offensive and hurting people? And even if you do think this, do you honestly believe that anything should be done to change the tradition?
There have been various attempts to make the helpers of Sinterklaas more neutral in the color of their skin. One initiative was to introduce "Rainbow Piet" but this was met with death threats. (Here is an interesting website that shows the history of Zwarte Piet, the changes he has undergone in the past, and the possible story that could be used in order to introduce Rainbow Piet: http://www.stnicholascenter.org/pages/zwarte-piet/) Another was "Natural Piet" but this too was not accepted. Do you think that it would be easier to change the color of Zwarte Piet's skin if "Zwarte" wasn't part of his name? For instance, if the character had always been known as simply "Piet" or "Piet de Nuttig" do you think it would be easier to change a characteristic, such as the color of the skin? Perhaps a different approach could be taken... Do you think that if other racial characteristics were taken away (large red lips, curly black hair, gold hoops, etc.), would it matter as much that their skin was painted black? Do you think that black can ever really be just a color when it is painted on someone's skin?
Finally, do you think that this is a tradition that is offensive and hurting people? And even if you do think this, do you honestly believe that anything should be done to change the tradition?
Zwarte Piet- Allen McClelland
My personal views on Zwarte Piet as a character and as a tradition are NOT as important as my desire to understand the importance of the character to the Dutch people, and where the seemingly unanimous defensive attitude towards the Sinterklaas tradition comes from.
It seems very strange that a country that has been through so much change in the past fifty years would be so opposed to changing the character of Zwarte Piet and therefore the Sinterklaas tradition in this, of all circumstances, when this holiday relates not only to ethnicity but to religion as well.
Looking from the outside, the Netherlands has made incredibly progressive choices in the formation of it's current identity. Shedding religion, homophobia, and a remarkable volume of tradition, the Netherlands appear as an incredibly pragmatic and rational society, not only when compared with other European countries but also when compared to America itself. Honestly, Dutch society trumps many aspects of American society, allowing citizens to love and marry who they desire, eliminating stigmas about soft drugs, regulating the phenomenon of prostitution instead of fighting it and putting prostitutes in an even more delicate predicament, and letting go of religious zealotry. But one thing I cannot wrap my head around is why this character and this tradition are so important in the midst of all of this.
Sinterklaas, to my understanding, follows that St. Nicholas was an ex-pope, an incredibly powerful figure of the Christian religion. Clearly stemming from a religion that remarkably few Dutch people practice, it's hard to understand why the tradition is so dear to the Dutch people. I'm actually surprised there isn't more ambiguity in the argument, if presented with this scenario of Sinterklaas and the tradition, without knowing how Americans felt about it collectively, or knowing how the Dutch feel about it collectively, I would expect (as usual) America to want to get involved and to try to change Sinterklaas, which it has. But, I would also expect the Dutch people to shrug their shoulders, rather than take up arms for their holiday tradition, as I really would not expect it to be a big deal to the Dutch people, the "sacredness" of an old tradition seems a very strange platform for a people who have embraced change so actively and repeatedly over the past half-century.
Then bring in Zwarte Piet.
Suddenly we have a catalyst for conflict. With racism and discrimination still so prevalent in the world, it is a trigger for arguments to imitate any one race. This is why the tradition of "black face" baffles so many Americans, because if the argument is so mundane and trivial, why does it truly matter if it is changed?
Why should the Dutch care if Piet is no longer Zwarte, and if Piet had many colors? Especially if it breeds so much bad publicity and so many arguments to keep the tradition withstanding. Why not identify Piet based on his (quite noticable!) outfit, or on his behavior, or even on the make-up on the lips? A white Dutch man can just as easily be identified as one of St. Nicholas' helpers if he wears the outfit and wears bright make-up on his lips, and proceeds to hang around St. Nicholas and act as a Piet traditionally would, so why is it necessary that he have a black face?
I know that the Dutch do not see Zwarte Piet as racist, and I know you will read 100 arguments for why it is from my fellow American bloggers, so instead of arguing whether Zwarte Piet is racist or not, I merely want to ask what the big deal is for the Dutch People, the most pragmatic, negotation-friendly, adaptive society around, in changing one detail of an old religious holiday to avoid all of this controversy and nation-wide sensationalism?
This being said, I understand that I see through an "American" lens and that I am by no means Dutch, and so I would like to hear responses on my argument, so I can hope to understand the Dutch point of view on this issue. Thank you for your time.
-Allen McClelland
It seems very strange that a country that has been through so much change in the past fifty years would be so opposed to changing the character of Zwarte Piet and therefore the Sinterklaas tradition in this, of all circumstances, when this holiday relates not only to ethnicity but to religion as well.
Looking from the outside, the Netherlands has made incredibly progressive choices in the formation of it's current identity. Shedding religion, homophobia, and a remarkable volume of tradition, the Netherlands appear as an incredibly pragmatic and rational society, not only when compared with other European countries but also when compared to America itself. Honestly, Dutch society trumps many aspects of American society, allowing citizens to love and marry who they desire, eliminating stigmas about soft drugs, regulating the phenomenon of prostitution instead of fighting it and putting prostitutes in an even more delicate predicament, and letting go of religious zealotry. But one thing I cannot wrap my head around is why this character and this tradition are so important in the midst of all of this.
Sinterklaas, to my understanding, follows that St. Nicholas was an ex-pope, an incredibly powerful figure of the Christian religion. Clearly stemming from a religion that remarkably few Dutch people practice, it's hard to understand why the tradition is so dear to the Dutch people. I'm actually surprised there isn't more ambiguity in the argument, if presented with this scenario of Sinterklaas and the tradition, without knowing how Americans felt about it collectively, or knowing how the Dutch feel about it collectively, I would expect (as usual) America to want to get involved and to try to change Sinterklaas, which it has. But, I would also expect the Dutch people to shrug their shoulders, rather than take up arms for their holiday tradition, as I really would not expect it to be a big deal to the Dutch people, the "sacredness" of an old tradition seems a very strange platform for a people who have embraced change so actively and repeatedly over the past half-century.
Then bring in Zwarte Piet.
Suddenly we have a catalyst for conflict. With racism and discrimination still so prevalent in the world, it is a trigger for arguments to imitate any one race. This is why the tradition of "black face" baffles so many Americans, because if the argument is so mundane and trivial, why does it truly matter if it is changed?
Why should the Dutch care if Piet is no longer Zwarte, and if Piet had many colors? Especially if it breeds so much bad publicity and so many arguments to keep the tradition withstanding. Why not identify Piet based on his (quite noticable!) outfit, or on his behavior, or even on the make-up on the lips? A white Dutch man can just as easily be identified as one of St. Nicholas' helpers if he wears the outfit and wears bright make-up on his lips, and proceeds to hang around St. Nicholas and act as a Piet traditionally would, so why is it necessary that he have a black face?
I know that the Dutch do not see Zwarte Piet as racist, and I know you will read 100 arguments for why it is from my fellow American bloggers, so instead of arguing whether Zwarte Piet is racist or not, I merely want to ask what the big deal is for the Dutch People, the most pragmatic, negotation-friendly, adaptive society around, in changing one detail of an old religious holiday to avoid all of this controversy and nation-wide sensationalism?
This being said, I understand that I see through an "American" lens and that I am by no means Dutch, and so I would like to hear responses on my argument, so I can hope to understand the Dutch point of view on this issue. Thank you for your time.
-Allen McClelland
Is Zwarte Piet Racist?
From my perspective, it is hard to say. One has to begin by determining if racism can be inherent. I don't believe Zwarte Piet is intended to be racist, at least not in this day and age. It seems to me to be more of a continued tradition than an intentional overt display of racism. However, it is still offensive to many people of color. Here it is not intent, but perceived response that matters. If something is offensive to a specific racial group, then that thing is racist. In this case it is not what Zwarte Piet represents that determines if it is racist or not, but how it makes certain racial groups feel. It directly offends people of color in the Netherlands.
In America, there is a hugely charged atmosphere regarding race relations. For example, just in the last week or so a trend was started on Twitter where black students described their specific experiences here, at the University of Michigan (#bbum or "being black at UMich"). This was without any specific incident acting as a prompt; it was just a general venting of frustration and anger over feeling mistreated. If something such as Zwarte Piet were to be introduced here, into this sort of atmosphere, there would be nothing short of full scale protests, maybe an organized march on the capitol or two. People would not accept such a tradition whether they were black or white because it would be seen as horrifyingly racist.
I understand that it is one of the last real traditions in the Netherlands. I don't however, believe that modifying the tradition to make Zwarte Piet less offensive would harm the tradition in any way. The parades, the excitement, and all the usual events surrounding the tradition can remain the same. The only change required to make this tradition fun for everyone is to take the black out of the subservient "black Pete." For example, I've heard of attempts to just have a "natural" Pete, where the actors that play Pete simply don't use black face and retain their natural skin color. Other attempts at reconciliation have been rainbow Petes. Neither of these solutions will have any detrimental effect on the overall tradition of Sinterklaas, but they will remove the racism that surrounds it.
So yes, I suppose I do believe Zwarte Piet is racist, and all other considerations (such as "its tradition," or "it isn't intended to be racist") are irrelevant. To make Sinterklaas a wholesome, enjoyable tradition for everyone in the Netherlands, Zwarte Piet should be changed to remove the inherent racism.
I look forward to hearing your response! I'm very interested to hear your opinion on the topic.
-Jonah Harmon
In America, there is a hugely charged atmosphere regarding race relations. For example, just in the last week or so a trend was started on Twitter where black students described their specific experiences here, at the University of Michigan (#bbum or "being black at UMich"). This was without any specific incident acting as a prompt; it was just a general venting of frustration and anger over feeling mistreated. If something such as Zwarte Piet were to be introduced here, into this sort of atmosphere, there would be nothing short of full scale protests, maybe an organized march on the capitol or two. People would not accept such a tradition whether they were black or white because it would be seen as horrifyingly racist.
I understand that it is one of the last real traditions in the Netherlands. I don't however, believe that modifying the tradition to make Zwarte Piet less offensive would harm the tradition in any way. The parades, the excitement, and all the usual events surrounding the tradition can remain the same. The only change required to make this tradition fun for everyone is to take the black out of the subservient "black Pete." For example, I've heard of attempts to just have a "natural" Pete, where the actors that play Pete simply don't use black face and retain their natural skin color. Other attempts at reconciliation have been rainbow Petes. Neither of these solutions will have any detrimental effect on the overall tradition of Sinterklaas, but they will remove the racism that surrounds it.
So yes, I suppose I do believe Zwarte Piet is racist, and all other considerations (such as "its tradition," or "it isn't intended to be racist") are irrelevant. To make Sinterklaas a wholesome, enjoyable tradition for everyone in the Netherlands, Zwarte Piet should be changed to remove the inherent racism.
I look forward to hearing your response! I'm very interested to hear your opinion on the topic.
-Jonah Harmon
zwarte piet Katie Vandervoort
We have researched and discussed a lot about Zwarte Piet in this class. When I first saw a video that had Zwarte Piet in it, I was shocked. "Black Face" is a very taboo thing in America. It's seen as extremely racist and is very rarely seen anymore. From my understanding, people in the Netherlands do not intend any harm with Zwarte Piet. They don't mean for it to be racist, but I can definitely see how black people would be offended by this tradition. It would be interesting to know how you see the tradition. Can you understand how black people would be offended by it, or do you see no harm in it? Also, do you think that this tradition will be banned/changed?
Zwarte Piet
As an American, I have the capability of seeing the Zwarte Piet issue from a different perspective, through a different cultural lens. I think a reason that this debate is raging is that many people do not see the racism involved in the Zarte Piet tradition. I don't believe any Dutch person would intentionally take action to offend someone, but I think many people don't realize its effects. Those that take offense have for a long time had no voice on this matter, but are just now coming out into the open to share their feelings about Zwarte Piet. My advice, listen to what they have to say. It may surprise you.
And I don't want to come across as a condescending foreigner saying, "Shame on you!" so I'll give you an example of this that exists in America. Here, we have various sports franchises and other groups that have for a long time offended various Native American tribes. The professional football team, the Washington Redskins, as well as the baseball team, the Cleveland Indians both bear Native Americans as their mascots. Throughout the years, various groups have shown their outrage at these teams and would love to see their names changed. They find it very disrespectful to see their culture depicted as simplistic, brutal fighters. However, franchise owners and sports fans don't want to change. They are not intending to be racist, and they don't want to change tradition. And more than likely, change will not come for a long time if at all. As a more or less neutral observer (I am not Native American, nor do I pay close attention to sports) it is still difficult for me to desire a change. Part of me wants to believe that nobody finds these teams very offensive, but a part of me knows this is not true. If more voices spoke out and shared that they were truly, deeply hurt, I would be very much inclined to change the franchise names.
And I don't want to come across as a condescending foreigner saying, "Shame on you!" so I'll give you an example of this that exists in America. Here, we have various sports franchises and other groups that have for a long time offended various Native American tribes. The professional football team, the Washington Redskins, as well as the baseball team, the Cleveland Indians both bear Native Americans as their mascots. Throughout the years, various groups have shown their outrage at these teams and would love to see their names changed. They find it very disrespectful to see their culture depicted as simplistic, brutal fighters. However, franchise owners and sports fans don't want to change. They are not intending to be racist, and they don't want to change tradition. And more than likely, change will not come for a long time if at all. As a more or less neutral observer (I am not Native American, nor do I pay close attention to sports) it is still difficult for me to desire a change. Part of me wants to believe that nobody finds these teams very offensive, but a part of me knows this is not true. If more voices spoke out and shared that they were truly, deeply hurt, I would be very much inclined to change the franchise names.
Is Zwarte Piet Racist
I know that Zwarte Piet has been a fixture in Dutch tradition for a very long time. Some believe that Zwarte Piet is racist because of his history and because of his black face and attire; others believe that he is part of Dutch culture and couldn't be construed as racist.
I personally have mixed feelings on the subject. I don't believe that anyone is trying to hold discriminatory feelings toward colored people by supporting Zwarte Piet. Zwarte Piet is simply a tradition that those people want to hold on to. I also can understand why some people might get upset by the image of Zwarte Piet. To them Zwarte Piet might appear as Sinterklaas' slave. The goofy attire of Zwarte Piet might also be considered as offensive.
Here in America we have a similar debate that is happening. For years American sports teams have used names and mascots that refer to Native American tribes and people. These mascots and names often reinforce stereotypes about Native Americans, and are sometimes viewed as derogatory in nature. Because of this controversy organizations like the NCAA (National Collegiate Athletics Association), have decided to ban the use of mascots that depict Native Americans in an unfitting way. Native Americans have begun movements to get the names of these mascots changed. Many non-Native Americans believe that the names have no intent to be offensive and believe the names should be kept out of tradition. So this whole scenario could be considered very similar to the situation with Zwarte Piet.
So in the end I believe that while the intent for Zwarte Piet to be racist isn't there; there are still racist undertones to the character of Zwarte Piet. I'm not Dutch, have never been to Holland, and have never personally experienced a Zwarte Piet celebration so I can't really decide what should be done, if anything, about this so that will be a decision left up to the Dutch.
Zwarte Piet: Grace Sheppard
When I first heard about "Zwarte Piet" I immediately thought about how there would be utter chaos in the United States today if that was still around. I think that as an American, and with my country's history of slavery of African Americans in mind, the act of being in "black face" is extremely insulting and hurtful. It is a scandal when there is news about people dressing up in "black face" for Halloween.
I can see how the situation gets confusing because Zwarte Piet is part of your holiday tradition and that the intent is not supposed to be hurtful. But, even if the intent is not meant to be hurtful that does not make it impossible to hurting people in the process. I think it is important to put yourself in a different perspective to see how this holiday tradition is not jolly for everyone. What are your opinions on Zwarte Piet and do you think this tradition can be racist or insulting? Before Zwarte Piet was brought up in the news did you ever consider it to be offensive?
I can see how the situation gets confusing because Zwarte Piet is part of your holiday tradition and that the intent is not supposed to be hurtful. But, even if the intent is not meant to be hurtful that does not make it impossible to hurting people in the process. I think it is important to put yourself in a different perspective to see how this holiday tradition is not jolly for everyone. What are your opinions on Zwarte Piet and do you think this tradition can be racist or insulting? Before Zwarte Piet was brought up in the news did you ever consider it to be offensive?
Andrew Baker
Hello! My name is Andrew Baker, and I am a 27 year old student at the University of Michigan. I am a senior in my 4th year, and am studying Political Science and History. I spent most of my early and mid 20s working full-time in a factory, and touring and playing in punk rock bands, and am now finishing my education here. I still play in a band, but not as seriously as I used to. I am from the city of Warren in Michigan, which is a suburb just outside of Detroit. I currently have family living in Zwolle, Utrecht, and Wassenaar and have been to the Netherlands twice myself. My Oma is from Arnhem and my Opa from Wassenaar, and they moved to the United States in the 1950s. Ich kann nicht Niederländisch sprechen, aber ich kann ein Bisschen Deutsch sprechen. Meine Lehrerin für diese Klasse war auch meine Deutsch Lehrerin. I'm attaching a picture
Zwarte Piet discussion with Ben Creekmore
Is Zwarte Piet racist or not? This is a complex question. My personal opinion is that the tradition is not racist in itself, but the character of Zwarte Piet is to an extent. The tradition started of as an innocent holiday, just like the many we have in America. As time progressed, the holiday was looked at with a different perspective. The character Zwarte Piet became offensive to many other people, especially those of color. This can be seen as someone taking something out of context or too literal, or that person can be completely justified in their reasoning. As a society, people have to be respectable of everyone's views. This has to be true for both sides of belief, and everyone needs to poses objectivity to a certain degree. The fact that the tradition has been around for such a long time adds more complexity. People are always opposed to change. As a group, people tend to hide behind the fallacy that just because something has always been done like this in the past, that it should always be like that. I understand this as America went through the similar changes during the Civil Rights movement. This is still no reason to oppose change. As a society, we have to embrace change and accept it. However, this takes time and patience by both sides is needed. The people who find Zwarte Piet offensive must stand up for their beliefs but have an understanding that the changes may take time.
I, as an American, do not like to be criticized about my beliefs and opinions. I understand why many Dutch citizens take offense to many nations addressing this issue, but in order for change to occur, this is a necessary process. I believe some small changes can be made to the character of Zwarte Piet to take away the racist aspect that people see while still preserving the holiday and tradition.
Verandering is een noodzakelijk proces voor ons om te groeien als samenleving.
I, as an American, do not like to be criticized about my beliefs and opinions. I understand why many Dutch citizens take offense to many nations addressing this issue, but in order for change to occur, this is a necessary process. I believe some small changes can be made to the character of Zwarte Piet to take away the racist aspect that people see while still preserving the holiday and tradition.
Verandering is een noodzakelijk proces voor ons om te groeien als samenleving.
Zwarte Piet - Taylor Hunter
Hello again,
Zwarte Piet is very new to me; most Americans do not even know about the Dutch Holiday. When our introduction to Dutch class learned about this holiday, many instantly thought it represented racism. In America, the idea of painting one's face black is treated as a taboo! However, I can see why there is so much controversy about this topic in the Netherlands. Zwarte Piet is tradition; changing something that is traditional is a difficult thing to achieve. It's a little frightening to change traditional ways after having so many memories associated with that tradition. When I think about my childhood memories, the happiest times I had involved traditional holidays such as Christmas and Halloween. If one of those traditions were to loose some of its traditional characteristics (such as Santa Klaus being replaced by Mrs. Klaus), it would be weird for me.
Though, traditions are bound to change when controversy arises. For example, women's rights in the United States: it was tradition that women could not vote. However, it was problematic and was bound to change; it may had been hard for the people at the time to accept this change, but today, it is completely normal to see women vote.
Basically, what I'm getting at is that it might be hard to change something that has so many memories associated with it, but if it makes others feel marginalized it needs to change! I not saying Dutch people are intentionally being racism, I'm saying that this tradition needs to change because it represents racism.
Hope to hear from you soon!
Taylor
Zwarte Piet is very new to me; most Americans do not even know about the Dutch Holiday. When our introduction to Dutch class learned about this holiday, many instantly thought it represented racism. In America, the idea of painting one's face black is treated as a taboo! However, I can see why there is so much controversy about this topic in the Netherlands. Zwarte Piet is tradition; changing something that is traditional is a difficult thing to achieve. It's a little frightening to change traditional ways after having so many memories associated with that tradition. When I think about my childhood memories, the happiest times I had involved traditional holidays such as Christmas and Halloween. If one of those traditions were to loose some of its traditional characteristics (such as Santa Klaus being replaced by Mrs. Klaus), it would be weird for me.
Though, traditions are bound to change when controversy arises. For example, women's rights in the United States: it was tradition that women could not vote. However, it was problematic and was bound to change; it may had been hard for the people at the time to accept this change, but today, it is completely normal to see women vote.
Basically, what I'm getting at is that it might be hard to change something that has so many memories associated with it, but if it makes others feel marginalized it needs to change! I not saying Dutch people are intentionally being racism, I'm saying that this tradition needs to change because it represents racism.
Hope to hear from you soon!
Taylor
Zwarte Piet - Jan Smith
Hallo.
The debate over Zwarte Piet is very surprising for most Americans. We have a concept of 'political correctness' here in the United States that makes things like Zwarte Piet taboo. Basically, we believe that if something will make other people feel hurt or upset, we should respect their feelings. Not every American likes the idea of political correctness. However, no American that I know would ever wear blackface, for any reason. That's how deeply engrained the taboo is here.
Although it's an American taboo, that doesn't mean it's a Dutch taboo. However, I would like to suggest that maybe Dutch people should make blackface a taboo as well. Here are a few reasons why.
- Zwarte Piet, despite what some people say, certainly does represent a person of African descent. Here is why.
- Origins: Zwarte Piet came into existence in the height of the colonial period, in the mid-19th century.
- Imagery: Zwarte Piet is dressed in clothes from an era in which black people were taken from their homeland and sold as slaves. Although the Netherlands hasn't had slavery, Dutch ships often carried slaves.
- In short, because of the history of the character, we cannot say that he is just a white boy who fell down a chimney. He was originally intended to be a black person, and his clothing shows that he still seen as a black person, from a very racist era.
- Your friends and fellow citizens are hurt by Zwarte Piet.
- This is the idea of 'political correctness'. You have the freedom to say and do what you want, but should you really do something that makes someone feel horrible?
- You don't have to get rid of Sinterklaas or Piet... just consider modifying the tradition.
- Sinterklaas is a beautiful festival. In America, where Christmas has become commercialized and commodified, nobody truly anticipates the holiday season. But my friends from Europe all talk about what a magical time of year it is. They talk about family, tradition, delicious food, and a magical quality that is foreign to most of us Americans.
- Zwarte Piet is ruining this tradition. The refusal to separate Zwarte Piet from Sinterklaas could ruin the holiday itself.
- In short, Sinterklaas isn't a racist holiday in and of itself... but it could be. If Zwarte Piet ruined the Sinterklaas festival, it would be truly tragic.
One last thought - consider your response to accusations of racism. We say in the US that the worst thing you can call a white person is racist. I'm white myself, and if someone told me I was racist, I would be very, very upset. But you shouldn't be angry. Instead you should think about what people are saying and try to see what they see. Usually, when someone says you did something racist, it's true... it doesn't mean you're racist as a person, but it means that something you did or said made them feel bad. Most racism is unintentional.
The way you respond to this makes a huge difference. If you get mad and aggressive, then that's even more racist. If you keep doing something even though you know it makes people feel horrible, then it becomes intentional. And if you intentionally do something racist, then maybe that does make you racist.
In short... no, the Netherlands is not a racist nation... no, Dutch people are not racist... no, Sinterklaas is not a fundamentally racist festival... but Zwarte Piet is a very, very racist character.
These are my thoughts. Feel free to take them or leave them,
- Jan
PS - here's an interesting link you might want to read. A bit about the history of blackface in the United States. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackface
Zwarte Piet - Flannery Dunn
Hallo!
Zwarte Piet is een heel interessant thema. Als een Amerikaanse, ik vind Zwarte Piet een beetje racistich. Ik weet Zwarte Piet is niet racistisch bedoeld, maar zwarte mensen zijn slecht afgebeeld. Als Zwarte Piet een andere kleur had, Zwarte Piet zou niet racistich zijn. Kinderen zijn dol op Zwarte Piet. De traditie moet niet eindigen, maar het moet een beetje veranderen.
I don't think the Dutch are racist, they grew up with Zwarte Piet and love him. But it creates a negative image for black people. They are being portrayed as a servant, someone there only for a laugh. I think that if the image of Zwarte Piet was changed, if he was blue or green or purple, there would be no issue. The fact that he looks like a racial stereotype is half of the problem. I think it is a nice tradition, but it needs a facial change.
I'm looking forward to hearing your opinion on Zwarte Piet! =]
~Flannery
Zwarte Piet is een heel interessant thema. Als een Amerikaanse, ik vind Zwarte Piet een beetje racistich. Ik weet Zwarte Piet is niet racistisch bedoeld, maar zwarte mensen zijn slecht afgebeeld. Als Zwarte Piet een andere kleur had, Zwarte Piet zou niet racistich zijn. Kinderen zijn dol op Zwarte Piet. De traditie moet niet eindigen, maar het moet een beetje veranderen.
I don't think the Dutch are racist, they grew up with Zwarte Piet and love him. But it creates a negative image for black people. They are being portrayed as a servant, someone there only for a laugh. I think that if the image of Zwarte Piet was changed, if he was blue or green or purple, there would be no issue. The fact that he looks like a racial stereotype is half of the problem. I think it is a nice tradition, but it needs a facial change.
I'm looking forward to hearing your opinion on Zwarte Piet! =]
~Flannery
Zwarte Pete -Maxwell Huntley
Hello my Dutch comrade, it has come
to my attention that a large portion of Dutch society does not find this “Black
Peter” debacle to be racist. It is true that I, as an American happen to be
quite sensitive towards “black face” due to my countries dark relationship with
slavery and our bloody past, but it is my belief that the opinions of those
most sensitive need to be weighed heavier than most. This idea that “Black
Peter” is a tradition and “for the kids” is an ignorant notion being used as a
scapegoat. If it is offensive to a few then it is a general rule of thumb that
it is most likely offensive. I understand that the Nederlands has a culture
that hasn’t been confronted with many allegations of racism. But as a citizen of
a country that is largely segregated (culturally) let me affirm the power of
racial sentiments. These issues are best dealt with before they can fester and
worsen. To lose a small portion of your tradition is preferable to alienating a
whole section of your country.
Zwarte Piet: Brian Cook
The problem with Americans seeing Zwarte Piet is that we had similar caricatures in our country in the early 20th century and it's something we look at with great shame. Zwarte Piet resembles Little Black Sambo, an incredibly offensive character in books and television that portrayed young black children.
Here are some examples of racism in American culture:
I was part of an American History class during my sophomore year of high school and we watched an hour-long documentary about racism in popular culture. It was incredibly shocking and every student left that room with little being said; it was a reminder of where our country was a few decades ago and it was horrifying.
I'm not going to say Zwarte Piet is overtly racist because I'm not familiar with how he is received by Dutch people. Our characters were used to mock African-Americans by appealing to stereotypes and growing the divisiveness in our country. From what I've seen, however, the reaction by Dutch people sympathetic to the Piet character is astounding. If the character itself isn't racist the malice towards reformers is disappointing to me.
Now I know that traditions are important and sometimes ones with racist tones are hard to overcome. For example there's a professional football team named the Washington Redskins, and that term is an offensive one for Native Americans.
So I think it's important that I emphasize that we aren't superior in race relations because we are in fact not very good at them. Going forward for our race problems and yours I think the biggest thing to remember is that traditions come and go, and that racial divisions aren't worth it in any case.
Christian Proebsting
Ik heet Christian en ben economie student op de universiteit van Michigan. Vroeger studeerde ik in Duitsland en Zwitzerland, maar nu ben ik al sinds drie jaar in Amerika om te doctoreren. Naar mijn studies in Duitsland heb ik voor vijf maanden een stage bij het Centraal Planbureau gelopen, om over de internationale handel van Nederlandse bedrijven onderzoek te doen. Ik ben vlak bij Muenster aan de Nederlandse grens opgegrooid, en had sommige contacten met Nederlanders. Bijvoorbeeld hadden we voetbal wedstrijden in Nederland (tegen Hector Goor), waar ik leerde van hagelslag en vla te houden. Een keer, toen ik van Michigan naar Berlijn ben gevlogen, had ik een overstap in Amsterdam Schiphol. Ik had een beetje tijd en ben naar buiten gegaan, om in Albert Heijn boodschappen te doen. Ik heb heel veel vla en stroopwaffels gekocht, om ze naar huis mee te nemen. Maar toen ik weer op mijn vliegtuig wilde, zeiden de controlleurs, dat de vla niet mee kon. Ik heb nog nooit zo veel vla op een moment gedronken. Ook met mijn gezin was ik vaak in Nederland om bij de vennen te fietsen. Ik hou heel erg van het fietsen en vind het heel leuk dat in Nederland zelfs de kleinste kinderen naar school fietsen. Daarom hou ik ook van deze link:
http://www.hetregentbijnanooit.nl/site/
http://www.hetregentbijnanooit.nl/site/
Hallo! Ik heet Gabe!
Hallo! Ik heet Gabe Schat. Ik ben seventeen jaren oud, ik zit op de middelbare school, maar ik heb een paar vakken op de Universiteit, Nederlands is een van mijn Universiteit vakken. Ik was in Ann Arbor Michigan geboren, maar heel veel van mijn familie kommen uit Nederland (toevallig, sommige van mijn famile leven rond Groningen).
Ik woon samen met mijn moeder en met mijn vier katten in Ann Arbor. Ik heb ook twee zussen die op Universiteit zitten. Toen ik een kind was heb ik Sinterklaas gevierd, maar Zwarte Pieten waren niet een groote deel van de vieringen. Ik denk dat Zwarte Pieten debat is een erg interessante fenomeen die heel veel implicaties voor de toekoemst van Nederlands hebben. Ik willen weten wat jullie denken over Zwarte Pieten.
Sunday, November 24, 2013
Hey there my Dutch friends! My name is Tyler Aronne and I am a freshman at the University of Michigan. I was born in New York and grew up about 30 minutes outside of NYC. I love soccer and play goalkeeper . Hopefully the US will impress in Brazil next year like the Orange did last World Cup. I also love playing lacrosse but I am not sure if you guys play in the Netherlands. Here's a link to a picture of me playing for my high school team:
Its an awesome sport thats incredibly fun and I suggest you try at least once. I've never been to the Netherlands but from what I've learned it sounds unbelievable and I look forward to visiting at some point. If you've never been to New York City I highly suggest visiting. It's not just big buildings and taxi cabs like some of you may think! Here's a picture of Central Park, which is one of my favorite parts of the city.
Well, thats all for now. I look forward to hearing back from you guys about Dutch culture and all that it has to offer!
-Tyler Aronne
Its an awesome sport thats incredibly fun and I suggest you try at least once. I've never been to the Netherlands but from what I've learned it sounds unbelievable and I look forward to visiting at some point. If you've never been to New York City I highly suggest visiting. It's not just big buildings and taxi cabs like some of you may think! Here's a picture of Central Park, which is one of my favorite parts of the city.
Well, thats all for now. I look forward to hearing back from you guys about Dutch culture and all that it has to offer!
-Tyler Aronne
Joseph Groulx
Hallo! Ik heet Joseph Groulx. Ik studeer aan de Universiteit van Michigan. Mijn concentratie is anthropology.
Op de moment, woon ik in Ann Arbor (de stadt van de universiteit). Mijn familie woont in een klein dorp. Het heet Munger, Michigan. Je kunt het vinden op Google Earth, maar het is zo klein (5,000 mensen)!
Sport je? Ik heb "cross country" elf jaar gelopen, en in 2011, ik heb mijn eerst marathon gerend. In augustus, echter, ik brak mijn hielen. Nu, ik bin volledig hersteld.
Wat studeert je? Wat is je favoriet tv-programma? Mijn is The Daily Show. Misschien, je kunt het programma kijken, ik bin niet zeker of het is zichtbaar.
Friday, November 22, 2013
Samantha Van Horn
Hallo!
Mijn naam is Samantha Van Horn. Ik heb achttien yaar oud. Ik ben geboren op 26 oktober 1995. Ik kom uit Ypsilanti Michigan. Ik studeren aan de Universiteit van Michigan. Mijn moeder is verpleegster, en mijn vader is boekhouder. Ik heb een broer. Hij is twintig yaar oud. Ik heb geen zussen. Ik hou van golf en country muziek. Ik heb enn huisdier vis. Ik hou kijken van sports met mijn vader. Ik hou van baseball. Mijn favorite team is de Detroit Tigers!
![]() |
| dit is de staduim waar ze spelen |
| Dis is me en mijn broer |
Hoe oud zijn jullie? Waar woon jullie? Wat doen jullie in je vrije tijd?
Thursday, November 21, 2013
Jeffrey Bennett
Hello! Mijn naam is Jeff. Ik kom uit Newburgh, New York. Het is een klein stad. Ik graag Amerikaans football maar ons team is dit jaar erg slecht. Ik ben zesentwintig en ik nu woon in Ann Arbor, Michigan. Ik studeer geologie. Ik heb zeven jaar in het leger voordat ik aanwezig bij de Universiteit van Michigan. Wat doen jullie studeren?
http://geology.com/plate-tectonics/
http://geology.com/plate-tectonics/
Flannery Dunn
Hallo! Mijn naam is Flannery Dunn. Ik kom uit Los Angeles. Ik studeer Asiatisch talen en cultuur (ik kun Chinees, Japans, en een beetje Spaans spreken). Ik studeer Nederlands omdat het is een leuke taal.
In mijn vrije tijd ik films kijken, muziek luisteren, graag videogames, en voeding eten. Mijn favoriet film is The Lion King!! Ik hou van naar concerten gaan. Deze zomer ik Lollapalooza in Chicago gaan. Mijn absolute favoriet band is Vampire Weekend. Ik zag ze op Lollapalooza (Dit is mijn favoriete liedje - Walcott! Ik vind Ezra (lead singer) veel knap hhahaha
In mijn vrije tijd ik films kijken, muziek luisteren, graag videogames, en voeding eten. Mijn favoriet film is The Lion King!! Ik hou van naar concerten gaan. Deze zomer ik Lollapalooza in Chicago gaan. Mijn absolute favoriet band is Vampire Weekend. Ik zag ze op Lollapalooza (Dit is mijn favoriete liedje - Walcott! Ik vind Ezra (lead singer) veel knap hhahaha
Jackie Khutorsky
Hi guys. My name is Jackie and I am currently an 18 year old freshman at the University of Michigan. Though I am not 100 percent decided, I am considering both Psychology and English for my major. Some things I enjoy are music, hanging out with friends, and obviously football Saturdays. What are some things you like to do? I'm also obsessed with the show The Office. Have you seen it?
I have lived all over America but I most currently live in Philadelphia, which is located about halfway between Washington D.C. and New York. It's a pretty cool city and is often called the city of brotherly love. This famous scene from the movie Rocky was filmed in Philadelphia: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NubH5BDOaD8. Besides my family and friends, the thing I miss the most from home is my little white fluffy dog whose name is Rio. He's super cute!
I also love to travel and have been to Europe several times. However, I've never been to the Netherlands and I am dying to go. From what we have learned in class, your country is awesome.
Below is a picture of my sister and me. Even though she's little (she's only 11), she is super funny and keeps me young.
Can't wait to hear from you.
I have lived all over America but I most currently live in Philadelphia, which is located about halfway between Washington D.C. and New York. It's a pretty cool city and is often called the city of brotherly love. This famous scene from the movie Rocky was filmed in Philadelphia: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NubH5BDOaD8. Besides my family and friends, the thing I miss the most from home is my little white fluffy dog whose name is Rio. He's super cute!
I also love to travel and have been to Europe several times. However, I've never been to the Netherlands and I am dying to go. From what we have learned in class, your country is awesome.
Below is a picture of my sister and me. Even though she's little (she's only 11), she is super funny and keeps me young.
Can't wait to hear from you.
![]() |
| Me and my sister Katia |
![]() |
| The famous LOVE statue in Philadelphia |
Ben Creekmore
Hallo!! Mijn naam is Ben Creekmore. Ik kom uit Kingston, Tennessee. Het is een klein dorp. Ik ben zesentwintig. Ik ben geboren op vierde maart. Hoe oud ben je? Ik woon in Ann Arbor, Michigan waar ik bijwonen van de Universiteit van Michigan. Het is erg moeilijk voor mij. Ik heb zes jaar in de United States Navy. Het was een fantastisch ervaring. Ik willen lopen en tillen gewichten. Wat sport je?
http://www.public.navy.mil/subfor/csg10/Boat%20Pages/Wyoming.aspx
http://www.public.navy.mil/subfor/csg10/Boat%20Pages/Wyoming.aspx
Zak Piech
Hello! My name is Zak Piech and I'm a freshman at the University of Michigan. I'm from a small town in New Jersey, about 45 minutes outside of New York City. My grandparents are Dutch came to America from the Netherlands in the 1950's. I've visited the Netherlands before with my parents and still have cousins in Holland I keep in touch with. I have two older brothers, one who lives in Philadelphia and another who lives in Missouri. My favorite sports are hockey and American football. I used to play football in high school but now I just watch it. My favorite professional team is the New York Giants. I love going into New York and seeing concerts, games, or shows.
This is a picture of the Giants' stadium during a home game.
I alsot really love to travel. My favorit place I've been to so far is Kauai which is one of the Hawaiian Islands. I went with my family a couple of years ago. Here is a link to a random video I found that shows how beautiful it is. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uBLccEDmn40
I'm excited to learn about you and hear your thoughts!
Thanks
Zak Piech
This is a picture of the Giants' stadium during a home game.
I'm excited to learn about you and hear your thoughts!
Thanks
Zak Piech
Moriah Stapf
Hi!
My name is Moriah. I am 18 years old and from Calabasas, California. I currrently am a freshman at The University of Michigan. I am undecided in my major, and I am taking a variety of classes in order to figure out what I am interested in. I am taking this class on Tolerance and the history of the Netherlands because I find it very interesting and because some of my dads family lives there. When I was younger I traveled to Amsterdam, and I am looking forward to hopefully going back soon and maybe even studying there in the future.
In California, some of my hobbies include going to the beach and paddle-boarding, going on hikes, playing tennis, and just hanging out with my friends and family. My family and I spend a lot of time at the beach in Malibu, California and also a lot of time in the snow in Mammoth, California. I have a very big family and we love spending time together. My cousins and aunt and uncles and grandparents are all very close and we all live in Los Angeles so we get to see each other a lot, which is so much fun!
Here at U of M, I am in a sorority called Chi Omega. The sorority has 62 other girls my age and a lot of other older girls in it as well. Chi Omega has been a great opportunity for me to make friends and to be involved in fun social events. Every weekend we go to parties at different fraternity houses, and we also have fun charity events. My favorite days so far here at Michigan have been football saturdays... we all get up really early and get dressed up in our school colors and have tail gates to get ready for the game. What do you do for fun and as your night life?
Heres a picture of me and my brother on a football Saturday here at Michigan
My name is Moriah. I am 18 years old and from Calabasas, California. I currrently am a freshman at The University of Michigan. I am undecided in my major, and I am taking a variety of classes in order to figure out what I am interested in. I am taking this class on Tolerance and the history of the Netherlands because I find it very interesting and because some of my dads family lives there. When I was younger I traveled to Amsterdam, and I am looking forward to hopefully going back soon and maybe even studying there in the future.
In California, some of my hobbies include going to the beach and paddle-boarding, going on hikes, playing tennis, and just hanging out with my friends and family. My family and I spend a lot of time at the beach in Malibu, California and also a lot of time in the snow in Mammoth, California. I have a very big family and we love spending time together. My cousins and aunt and uncles and grandparents are all very close and we all live in Los Angeles so we get to see each other a lot, which is so much fun!
Here at U of M, I am in a sorority called Chi Omega. The sorority has 62 other girls my age and a lot of other older girls in it as well. Chi Omega has been a great opportunity for me to make friends and to be involved in fun social events. Every weekend we go to parties at different fraternity houses, and we also have fun charity events. My favorite days so far here at Michigan have been football saturdays... we all get up really early and get dressed up in our school colors and have tail gates to get ready for the game. What do you do for fun and as your night life?
Heres a picture of me and my brother on a football Saturday here at Michigan
Heres another picture of where I live in Malibu, CA
Cammie Finch
Hallo! Ik heet Cammie! Ik ben 19 jaar. Ik ben een student aan de Universiteit van Michigan. Ik studeer Engels Literatuur en Creatief Schrijven. Ik wil schrijver worden. Ik hou van hoelahoepen. Ik hoelahoep voor twee uur per dag. Ik drink veel thee en koffie elke dag. Geen suiker, geen melk. Thee en koffie zijn erg lekker. Ik ben gek op voetbal op de TV kijken. Mijn favoriete voetballers zijn Dirk Kuyt en Thomas Muller. Ik bezocht Amsterdam in 2010. Het is heel mooi! Ik hou van reizen. Ik wil jullie ontmoeten.
Wat vinden jullie leuk? Ik hou van lezen en schrijven en schilderen! Mijn favoriete film is Breakfast at Tiffany's met Audrey Hepburn. Ik heb een kat. Zij heet Saki. Ik ben klein met kort bruine haar en bruin ogen. Mijn favoriete kleurs zijn turkoois en zilver.
Hebben jullie ooit naar Amerika geweest?
Tot later!
Je vriendin,
Cammie Finch
Wat vinden jullie leuk? Ik hou van lezen en schrijven en schilderen! Mijn favoriete film is Breakfast at Tiffany's met Audrey Hepburn. Ik heb een kat. Zij heet Saki. Ik ben klein met kort bruine haar en bruin ogen. Mijn favoriete kleurs zijn turkoois en zilver.
Hebben jullie ooit naar Amerika geweest?
Tot later!
Je vriendin,
Cammie Finch
jackson, mi - ik kom uit Jackson.
Naomi Spoelman
Hoi! Mijn naam is Naomi en ik studeer op de Unversiteit van Michigan. Ik ben 21 jaar en ben op mijn laatste jaar van de universiteit. Ik studeer Communicatie en Internationale studies met de meeste passie voor het milieu. Ik vind het heel interesant hoe klimaatverandering zou het nederlands outvoeren. Ik weet dat zeespiegelstijging is een grote zaak maar wat anders? Denken jullie vaak over klimaatverandering?
Toen ik een kind was, woonde ik op een boerderij van herten. De naam van het is "West Michigan Whitetails" (http://westmichiganwhitetails.com/). Ik hou van natuur en dieren. Mijn favoriete activiteiten zijn landlopen, kamperen, en bezoeken op nationale parken. Wat vinden jullie de meeste leuk en wat doen jullie met jou vrije tijd?
Toen ik een kind was, woonde ik op een boerderij van herten. De naam van het is "West Michigan Whitetails" (http://westmichiganwhitetails.com/). Ik hou van natuur en dieren. Mijn favoriete activiteiten zijn landlopen, kamperen, en bezoeken op nationale parken. Wat vinden jullie de meeste leuk en wat doen jullie met jou vrije tijd?
Alex Snow
Hi! My name is Alex and I am 18 years old. I currently attend the University of Michigan, where I am planning on studying for medical school. During the week, I can have anywhere from 2- 5 classes, which is about 2-8 hours of class per day. I usually have about an hour to an hour and a half of homework for each of those classes so my weekday schedules for classes are kind of hectic. Here in America, most people (especially men) watch American football and basketball as entertainment. In college these sporting events are usually accompanied by people called "cheerleaders." Cheerleaders are people who try to get the crowd more excited for the game and provide some sort of entertainment during breaks in the game. There are both male and female cheerleaders who perform during the games. I am one of the male cheerleaders. Male cheerleaders can do some of the most amazing things. Much of what the male cheerleaders do is called stunting. Stunting is kind of hard to explain but basically it is when a male cheerleader throws a girl cheerleader in the air and catches her in different kinds of positions. both male and female cheerleaders do "tumbling." Tumbling is pretty much the floor part of gymnastics. If you want to see exactly what I am talking about for tumbling and stunting here is a video. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KCEUsrZniEk This video takes place at Stuntfest during the the nationals competition. Every year in America, there is a national cheer leading competition. Teams from all over the country meet in Daytona, Florida to determine who is the best team.
During the summer, I spend much of my time at the lakes that are placed around my home. There my friends I do anything from swimming, to fishing, to boat rides, to wakeboarding. If you don't know what wakeboarding is, its kind of like a mix between water skiing and surfing. it looks like this. just enter i this url.
http://www.smartcharteribiza.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/ibiza-wakeboard-water-sports.jpg
On the weekends throughout the year, I spend my time hanging out and partying with friends, and doing homework.
Sorry I wrote for so long,
Alex Snow
During the summer, I spend much of my time at the lakes that are placed around my home. There my friends I do anything from swimming, to fishing, to boat rides, to wakeboarding. If you don't know what wakeboarding is, its kind of like a mix between water skiing and surfing. it looks like this. just enter i this url.
http://www.smartcharteribiza.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/ibiza-wakeboard-water-sports.jpg
On the weekends throughout the year, I spend my time hanging out and partying with friends, and doing homework.
Sorry I wrote for so long,
Alex Snow
Jonah Harmon
Hello! My name is Jonah Harmon, and I'm a first-year student at the University of Michigan. I'm 18 years old. I was born in Michigan, but I grew up in Canton, Ohio. I've traveled to Europe a few times, but I've never been to the Netherlands. Have you traveled much, domestically or internationally? I haven't had much chance to exercise recently, but I ran cross country and track in high school, and I've ran a total of 4 half-marathons and 1 full-marathon. What are your hobbies? I am studying Cell and Molecular Biology and Biomedical Engineering, with the end goal being a Master's degree in Biomedical Engineering. What sort of classes do you take at your school? We've been learning a lot about the differences between American and Dutch culture, and I'm sort of curious what most of you do for fun? I usually go out with friends, play pool (billiards I guess, I don't know if you guys call it pool there), or go for a run when I get the chance. I'm attaching as picture of the pro-football hall of fame (American football, sorry), because that was pretty much the only reason anyone would come to visit my hometown. I think I went maybe once. I don't really follow sports. There wasn't much to do in Canton, but I love Ann Arbor. It's a great city. How's your hometown? Anyway, hope to hear from you guys soon!

This is a picture of the finish line from the marathon I ran. I finished in 3:53:46, though (this person is not me, just a picture from Google).

This is the pro-football (American football) hall of fame, my hometown's only real attraction.
This is a picture of the finish line from the marathon I ran. I finished in 3:53:46, though (this person is not me, just a picture from Google).
This is the pro-football (American football) hall of fame, my hometown's only real attraction.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)










