While there is certainly an argument to be made that
tradition is important, traditions can and do change over time to suit shifting
cultural sensitivities. The character of
Zwarte Piet may not be intended as a racist caricature or meant to offend Black
people in the Netherlands or anywhere else in the world, but that doesn’t
change the fact that a great number of people see it as demeaning and detrimental
to their racial identity. It is not
enough to merely recognize the fact that people are offended by a particular
characteristic of the tradition (namely the painting of people’s faces), but
steps must be taken to adapt the tradition to changing cultural and racial
sensitivities. The United States had a
similar cultural institution at the end of the 1800s and into the first half of
the 1900s in the form of minstrelsy, which diminished in popularity over time
as people realized how offensive they were to some members of society. Even though some would argue that minstrel
shows were not intended to be racist or offensive and that there simply weren’t
Black performers available or allowed to play the roles in certain places, as
national awareness of racial identity and sensitivity grew, these traditions
were widely recognized as no longer being appropriate or acceptable. Minstrel shows are now almost virtually
condemned and seen as racist. Although
the Netherlands does not have the same complicated and volatile racial history
that the United States does, it is still important to recognize and respect the
impact that these traditions have on people and the offense that it
causes. To us in the United States, it
is almost unimaginable to think of a tradition like this continuing on into
this decade, but it is not fair to compare the histories and traditions of two
different countries. Comparison,
however, is not the point. The point is
simply this: it is important not only to
listen to the concerns, opinions, and complaints of Dutch citizens who are
opposed to and offended by the Zwarte Piet tradition. An on-going dialogue and discussion about the
social and cultural repercussions of this tradition must take place, and people
should be prepared to make changes to better accommodate the sensitivities of
those who find this tradition offensive.
No comments:
Post a Comment