Hallo!
I hope that everyone is having a good week. This will be my blog post about Zwarte Piet. I am going to try and be as impartial as possible.
In the United States, we have gone through years of the Civil Rights Movements, a battle that is still on going in order to ensure that the United States is a country where everyone can have equal rights. We have come a long way in government protected rights, especially for racial minorities and women, but we still have a lot to accomplish. I think that this movement has helped Americans to see that even unintentional racism can still be hurtful to others. However, we are still, Americans. It is a lot easier to critique a culture when we are looking from the outside in.
Both of my parents celebrated this tradition growing up. My dad grew up in a small Dutch neighborhood in Quebec. His parents immigrated there just a few months before he was born. My dad's recollection of the experience had nothing but positive things to say about Zwarte Piet. He talks about how Zwarte Piet would give him treats and help him get his present from Sinterklaas. It was a character he was fond of, helping him get to Sinterklaas.
However, the people acting as Zwarte Piets are not people of color, they are white, painting themselves black and fulfilling stereotypes of people of color. These Zwarte Piets have curly black hair, big red lips, and the way that Zwarte Piets act, enforces unfair stereotypes of people of color. Not all people of color run around doing flips nor are they any less intelligent.
Although years ago this tradition may not have seemed racist, the fact that people have come out and said that it hurts and offends them, shows that it is hurting part of your country. If this is one of your favorite holidays, would you not want to let everyone in The Netherlands celebrate it with the same excitement that you have? The entire situation seems like it is a lose-lose situation. Although it is a cherished holiday, it is still enforcing racial stereotypes of people of color. It is too bad that it has become a worldly issue rather than something that The Netherlands, as a country, could have solved on their own.
No comments:
Post a Comment