Hello my Dutch comrade, it has come
to my attention that a large portion of Dutch society does not find this “Black
Peter” debacle to be racist. It is true that I, as an American happen to be
quite sensitive towards “black face” due to my countries dark relationship with
slavery and our bloody past, but it is my belief that the opinions of those
most sensitive need to be weighed heavier than most. This idea that “Black
Peter” is a tradition and “for the kids” is an ignorant notion being used as a
scapegoat. If it is offensive to a few then it is a general rule of thumb that
it is most likely offensive. I understand that the Nederlands has a culture
that hasn’t been confronted with many allegations of racism. But as a citizen of
a country that is largely segregated (culturally) let me affirm the power of
racial sentiments. These issues are best dealt with before they can fester and
worsen. To lose a small portion of your tradition is preferable to alienating a
whole section of your country.
Hello Maxwell
ReplyDeleteI can see why people from America, see '''Zwarte Piet'' as racist, The black face, red lips, and golden ear rings. It stands for the time of slavery. But as i read through this, i think people are viewing this in a wrong way, because of the long bloody history. Your view on it is clouded, and it's hard to look at it from another standpoint.
For one, "Zwarte piet" has removed the red lips and rings for years, they weren't even around at the time when i was a kid. And i'm 17. Also most kids like Zwarte piet very much. they see them as comrades of ''Sinterklaas''
And be honest with me, isn't Santa Claus racist to? He is a fat person who can
protate Obeaceity in the Country's . And what about the elves? aren't they in the same position as our ''Zwarte Piet''? They work under a white skinned man, and are protait less importend and have specific tasks.
I do notice that every year all this whole discussion grows bigger. But you can't force a whole country to stop there 100 year tradition. A tradition, that helped starting Santa Claus (I mean the name comes from Sinterklaas, only made speakabale for english people....we call him Kerstman (Christmis man)) I think stopping Sinterklaas is the same as stopping Hanuka for Jewis people and Christmas for yours. I think we need to find a way that ether group will be happy. But personally i don't see the problem. i think people are over reacting to something small, Zwarte Piet, was never ment, and will never be protaid as racist.
From own experimence i was always looking more foreward to seeing them, then the Sint. Nicolaas himself