Zwarte Piet in Groningen

Zwarte Piet in Groningen

Sunday, December 1, 2013

Zwarte Piet- Jackie Khutorsky

As an American and as a person of non-African desent, I feel doubly removed from the Zwarte Piet debate that is currently transpiring within the Netherlands.  However, as someone who has experienced racism and is from a country with a dark history with slavery, I feel as though I have a different perspective to add to the Zwarte Piet debate.  Not long ago, black face was widely accepted within America.  In fact, the lead character in the 1927 movie The Jazz Singer, remains in black face for the majority of the movie.

Here is a picture:

As you can see, this character strongly resembles Zwarte Piet.  By using  stereotypical features like big lips, black skin, and tight curly black hair, the character in the movie and Zwarte Piet remain images that are offensive and disturbing to many people.  Instead of depicting a race in an honest way, both images rely on heavily biased and stereotypical conceptions that are overwhelmingly offensive.  Needless to say, dressing up in black face is no longer cultuarlly acceptable in America and should no longer be tolerated in the Netherlands as well.

While Zwarte Piet is understandably a favored and treasured tradition within in the Netherlands, why would a country that activaly promotes tolerance ever want to continue to offend thier citizens and other black people around the world by keeping Zwarte Piet?  No one wishes to abolish Zwarte Piet altogether but rather what if some slight adjustments were made?  Perhaps the Zwarte Piet could be rainbow or natural skin colored.  This would eliminate all offensive feelings while saving a tradition treasured by many Dutch people.  Though there is no denying that traditions are meant to be shared among many generations, there is no restriction on whether traditions can be slightly altered in order to become progressive and compliment with current social norms.  In conclusion, I think that the image of Zwarte Piet should be slightly altered in order to become non-offensive to all races.              

1 comment:

  1. I as Dutch citizen, can see why many American people see ''Zwarte Piet'' as racist.
    As i can clearly see from the pictures.

    But as someone who celebrated this holiday since child, it's hard to see.
    One as a child, you don't think about "Zwarte Piet'' as a slave, I personly saw him like a helper, like he worked for ''Sinterklaas'' Just like my parents worked for there bosses, and the teachers for there's.

    Also it's hard to just break a over 100th year tradition, we can't just stop from one on the other year. Also over years ''Zwarte Piet'' has changed over the years, when he was first intruduced, he couldn't talk very well, and was very scary. Nowadays, there even women "zwarte piet'' at the time that wasn't allowed, also they don't have the red lips, and ear rings. There now funny, most childeren like them even more then Sinterklaas.

    I also think taking our ''Zwarte Piet'' away is the same like taking the elves away from Santa Claus. I mean those are a little racist to if you think about it. They offend the little people who are controlled by a big, fat white person. That happend and is still happening now.

    But i do agree with you that we should make ''Zwarte Piet'' a little less racist, what we have done over the years, they don't look quite the same as they did when i was a child. But it's hard to saticify all people, that is something you can never accomplice, there will always someone be offended in some way.

    ReplyDelete