Zwarte Piet in Groningen
Sunday, December 8, 2013
Zwarte Piet - Sammy Pressman
The Zwarte Piet issue is a very interesting case which elicits a strong response from every side on the issue. To be honest, when I first heard about it, I did not care all that much, as I could not picture Zwarte Piet in my head so it did not seem like a huge deal to me. However, when I first saw a picture of Zwarte Piet, in what many Americans would call "black face", I was very shocked. That was my original ethnocentric reaction, as I am someone from a culture where black face is a huge taboo. For instance, if I were to dress up in a costume and use black face, no doubt many people here at the university would be disgusted. Yet Zwarte Piet must also be analyzed from a culturally relative position in order to understand it.
The main point about Zwarte Piet as a part of Dutch culture is that I do not think it is intentionally trying to be racist. Yet intentional or not, in the end it can still be construed as racist. However, this comes down to two very different countries with very different histories, which is why cultural relativism must come into play when thinking about this issue. The United States has a history of slavery and racism dating back hundreds of years, where blacks were marginalized and abused not only physically but socially too. Some of those impacts can still be seen today, in everything from the criminal justice system, where blacks are no doubt treated unfairly, to the educational system. The accumulation of these problems has led to a feeling of "white guilt" in our country, where many white people feel bad about the past and present treatment of minorities. As such, we feel that anything that offends them offends us, not because we can identify with how they feel, but because we feel bad that yet another bad thing is happening to them.
In the Netherlands, the opposite is true. While the Dutch held slaves, many of them were far off in the colonies, and those who lived in the mainland Netherlands were very disconnected from what was happening to the slaves. This is my explanation for why Zwarte Piet is not seen as racist by many Dutch. To you, it is merely tradition, something which has gone on for nearly a century and never faced scrutiny until very recently. Yet just because it has gone on for so long without scrutiny does not make it ok to continue. I know that it is very hard for you to understand why we think it is wrong. This is merely my opinion, and you have yours. I do not think that everything that offends somebody should be banned, that would lead to the banning of pretty much everything. However, Zwarte Piet, while not intentional, is still an accumulation of centuries of misfortune which are still affecting many today, and could be changed. I do not think the tradition needs to go away entirely, it seems very festive and fun, it should just be done in a way which can incorporate everyone. Once again, understand that this is only my ethnocentric opinion, and I am sure yours is very different.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I understand why many americans think ''Zwarte Piet'' is racist, i can see why and i know what a lot of people have done, i know what it can do to people, But i think what many people forget is that zwarte Piet has already changed a lot, When i was younger, he looked diffrent from when he does now, Back in the day he looked....well this is hard to explain....more "black" i suppose, I also know that at the time my parents where little, Zwarte Piet wasn't nice at all, he was the one that took you back to spain if you where naughty.
ReplyDeleteThis year was the first time in 8 years i watched news about Sinterklaas comming to the Netherlands again. Partly because he came to my home town, and partly because i wanted to see if i could have spotted my younger sister in the crowd.
But i noticed at the very beginning as i was watching how much has changed, for excample, there are a lot more female "zwarte pieten" when i was young it where mostly males. Also they don't wear the golden ear rings and don't have the red lips anymore, I know that has been for a few years, I don't know how old the pictures are that you are shown.
I do agree with you that we should try to make him less racist. But it's hard, how i see it, i don't see him as racist, it made me feel to like black people even more, that they could cool things. I don't know maybe that is just me. But i do think making zwarte piet disapear goes to far, goes many little childeren like them often a bit more than Sinterklaas