My only other experience with blackface was when I saw it used in two classic films: The Birth of a Nation, and The Jazz Singer. In the former film, blackface was worn by white actors to portray slaves in Antebellum South, primarily because the film was pro-Ku Klux Klan (associating the practice with racism).
seen here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Birth-of-a-nation-klan-and-black-man.jpg
In the latter, however, blackface is used as a sort of assimilation-agent -- the star was a Jewish immigrant -- used to usher in his career in the midst of an antisemitic America (applying a much more reasonable connotation to the practice).
seen here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Al_Jolson_Jazz_Singer.JPG
But is the festival actually racist? Surely the intent is for everyone to have a good time, but the disturbing underlying implications keep it from doing so. To be honest, I don't think the intent really matters; people are offended by it and we should respect their stance. If Amsterdam is truly as progressive as it prides itself to be, it should factor in all of its citizens' opinions, including those who find pain in the midst of others' joy.
Zwarte Piet, Why all the commotion?
ReplyDeleteThis week I read a (Dutch) blog regarding the subject. The story in this blog tells exactly how I think of the commotion regarding the subject. The story starts when the writer was traveling home from his work and someone was asking him what colour Zwarte Piet had is his village this year. Speechless he started thinking about the answer he should give.
The writer lived in Botswana for some years together with his family.
Quote:
My thoughts went back to the day our son became 10 years old. After school he celebrated his birthday with his friends. At the same time his grandmother from Holland called her grandson to congratulate him. As he came on the phone he told his granny about the party going on. Granny asked who were invited for the party. He told her: Tebogo, Mbanga, Kasigo, Mpho, Rrapula, Mbesi, Brian…. “Brian?” asked my mother as this was the first European name she heard. “Is Brian black or white?” (Not because of racism, just interest and to keep the conversation going on). Is Brian black or white? Our son had to think a moment…. About Brian…. His best friend.…Brian came along almost every day and in case Brian was not at our place, our son was at Brian’s place. Black or white? No clue! So he shouted “Briannnn!!!!!!!!”. The call was loud enough, Brian showed up within a few seconds. As he came in our son gesticulated to Brian it was all OK, he could go back to the other boys. Then he spoke in he phone: “He’s black grandma, black as the night”. Totally stunned I followed the conversation….. Although the two boys were always together at school and after school apparently they didn’t know each other’s colour. This detail is of such little importance they didn’t even ‘save’ this information.
Unquote.
“Sir?” the man waked up the writer. He was waiting for an answer. So I gave him the answer of a 10 year old: “I really don’t know, I will check next year!”.